Lecture 10
Return and Risk
Rates of Return
 A key measure of investors’ success is the
rate at which their funds have grown
 Holding-period return (HPR) of shares is
composed of capital gain and dividend
 RH = (C)+ (PE-PB) /PB
 This definition assumes end of period returns
and ignores re-investment of income
 Return Relative It is a different way to
calculate return. This method is used when a
cumulative wealth index or a geometric mean
has to be calculated.
Return Relative (RR)= C+PE/PB
Rates of Return
Rates of Return
 Dividend Yield = Percentage return from
dividends i.e. (D/PB)x100
 To calculate HPR over a period of time, we
can use:
 Arithmetic average
 Geometric average
 Dollar weighted return
Arithmetic Average
 It is the sum of periodic return divided by number of
periods
 Arithmetic Average = 15/3 = 5%
Period 1 10%
Period 2 25%
Period 3 -20%
Sum 15%
Geometric Average
nth root of the product of returns for n years
Geometric mean = (1+R1)x(1+R2)x(1+R3)1/n
– 1
 = [(1+10%) x (1+ 25%) x(1+(-20%))] 1/3
– 1
 [(1.1) x (1.25) x (.8)] 1/3
– 1
 (1.1) 1/3
– 1
 1.03-1
 .03 or 3%
Problem with Arithmetic
average
 Suppose the following:
 Calculating arithmetic mean gives false value of 25% return =
(100%-50%)/2
 And geometric = (1+1)x(1-.5)1/2
- 1
 =1-1 = 0%
Year Begin
value
Ending
value
HPR
2007 50 100 100%
2008 100 50 -50%
Geometric Vs Arithmetic
 In highly volatile security prices, arithmetic
mean is biased upward and we should use
geometric mean
 If rates of returns are the same for all years,
geometric and arithmetic averages gives
same results
Taking a Global
 When investors buy or sell securities in other
countries, they also take exchange rate risk
or currency risk
 Fluctuation in currency value can be either a
source of loss or profit
 If the foreign currency strengthens, your
returns will increase or vice versa
An Example
 Suppose you purchased 100 shares of IBM at NYSE for
$300 each. The dollar-rupee parity was 60 rupees a
dollar at the that time. So your total investment in rupees
was 100x$300 = $30000 x 60 =Rs.1800,000
 At the end of the year, IBM share price was $310, giving
you $10 profit per share, your profit is = 100 x 10 =
$1000x60 = Rs.60000
 But the dollar-rupee parity had jumped to 78 rupee a
dollar, now your total investment is =100x310 = $31000
x 78 = Rs.2418000
 And your profit is 2,418,000-180,0000 = Rs.618,000
 Or in percentage = 618,000/1800,000 = .343 or 34%
Equation for calculating
returns from foregin stocks
 = [(P1/Po)x(C1/Co)] – 1
 [(310/300)x(78/60)] – 1
 [(1.03) x (1.3)] – 1
 1.339 – 1
 0.339 or 34%
 P1 = Ending share price
 Po = Beginning share price
 C1 = Ending value of domestic currency
 Co = Beginning value of domestic currency
Risk
 Any investment involves some degree of
uncertainty about future returns
 Risk arises out of variability in returns
 If an asset has no variability in returns, the
assets is considered to be risk free like one
year T-bills
Type of Risk
Systematic Risk (Not diversifiable)
 Market Risk
 Interest Rate Risk
 Purchasing Power Risk
Unsystematic Risks (Diversifiable)
 Business Risk
 Financial risk
Sources of Risk
 Market risk : variability in returns due to
fluctuations in aggregate market
 Recession, wars etc
 Interest Rate Risk
Interest risk refers to variability of total returns,
particularly on fixed income securities due fluctuation in
Interest rates.
 Purchas Power or Inflation risk
 when purchasing power declines.
 Inflation also leads to hike in interest rates because
lenders demand more to compensate themselves for
loss in purchasing power
 Exchange risk = for international investors,
a source of risk come from exchange rate
fluctuation
 Country Risk = For international investors,
economic and political stability, law and order
situation are important consideration in the
investment decision
Sources of Risk
Interest rates and returns
 1. Increase in interest rates increases the
required rate of return
 RRR= Rf + Risk premium which reduces the
prices of the securities (intrinsic value)
 2. It increases cost of borrowing and hence cost
of capital
 3. It reduces money supply which lower demand
for securities and resultantly prices fall.
RRR
Cashflow
alueIntrinsicV
+
=
1
Measuring Risk
 The most commonly used measure of risk
for securities is standard deviation
 SD measure the total risk of a security or a
portfolio
 It measure deviations of each observation
from the arithmetic mean
1
]R-[R
1
2
_
i
−
=
∑=
n
n
i
σ
Measuring Risk
Standard Deviation
89.5
4
139
15
139
==
−
1
]R-[R
1
2
_
i
−
∑=
n
n
i
Interpretation
 The 5.89 SD means that the security return
can fluctuate between +/-5.89 from the mean
value of 16%
 More specifically, the return can fluctuate
between 16 - 5.89 = 10.11 or 16 + 5.89 =
21.89
Your return could fall to as low as
10.11% or could rise to 21.89 %
Realized Returns and risk
from Investing
Class of assets Average SD
S&P 500 Composite 9.21% 19.75%
S&P Industrial 9.66 21.57
S&P Utility 8.47 20.54
Small Cap Stock (S&P 600) 14.82 37.23
AAA 20-year Corp Bond 3.87 10.05
US 15-year Bond 3.25 10.22
T-Bills 1.569 4.65

Risk and Return

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Rates of Return A key measure of investors’ success is the rate at which their funds have grown  Holding-period return (HPR) of shares is composed of capital gain and dividend  RH = (C)+ (PE-PB) /PB  This definition assumes end of period returns and ignores re-investment of income
  • 3.
     Return RelativeIt is a different way to calculate return. This method is used when a cumulative wealth index or a geometric mean has to be calculated. Return Relative (RR)= C+PE/PB Rates of Return
  • 4.
    Rates of Return Dividend Yield = Percentage return from dividends i.e. (D/PB)x100  To calculate HPR over a period of time, we can use:  Arithmetic average  Geometric average  Dollar weighted return
  • 5.
    Arithmetic Average  Itis the sum of periodic return divided by number of periods  Arithmetic Average = 15/3 = 5% Period 1 10% Period 2 25% Period 3 -20% Sum 15%
  • 6.
    Geometric Average nth rootof the product of returns for n years Geometric mean = (1+R1)x(1+R2)x(1+R3)1/n – 1  = [(1+10%) x (1+ 25%) x(1+(-20%))] 1/3 – 1  [(1.1) x (1.25) x (.8)] 1/3 – 1  (1.1) 1/3 – 1  1.03-1  .03 or 3%
  • 7.
    Problem with Arithmetic average Suppose the following:  Calculating arithmetic mean gives false value of 25% return = (100%-50%)/2  And geometric = (1+1)x(1-.5)1/2 - 1  =1-1 = 0% Year Begin value Ending value HPR 2007 50 100 100% 2008 100 50 -50%
  • 8.
    Geometric Vs Arithmetic In highly volatile security prices, arithmetic mean is biased upward and we should use geometric mean  If rates of returns are the same for all years, geometric and arithmetic averages gives same results
  • 9.
    Taking a Global When investors buy or sell securities in other countries, they also take exchange rate risk or currency risk  Fluctuation in currency value can be either a source of loss or profit  If the foreign currency strengthens, your returns will increase or vice versa
  • 10.
    An Example  Supposeyou purchased 100 shares of IBM at NYSE for $300 each. The dollar-rupee parity was 60 rupees a dollar at the that time. So your total investment in rupees was 100x$300 = $30000 x 60 =Rs.1800,000  At the end of the year, IBM share price was $310, giving you $10 profit per share, your profit is = 100 x 10 = $1000x60 = Rs.60000  But the dollar-rupee parity had jumped to 78 rupee a dollar, now your total investment is =100x310 = $31000 x 78 = Rs.2418000  And your profit is 2,418,000-180,0000 = Rs.618,000  Or in percentage = 618,000/1800,000 = .343 or 34%
  • 11.
    Equation for calculating returnsfrom foregin stocks  = [(P1/Po)x(C1/Co)] – 1  [(310/300)x(78/60)] – 1  [(1.03) x (1.3)] – 1  1.339 – 1  0.339 or 34%  P1 = Ending share price  Po = Beginning share price  C1 = Ending value of domestic currency  Co = Beginning value of domestic currency
  • 12.
    Risk  Any investmentinvolves some degree of uncertainty about future returns  Risk arises out of variability in returns  If an asset has no variability in returns, the assets is considered to be risk free like one year T-bills
  • 13.
    Type of Risk SystematicRisk (Not diversifiable)  Market Risk  Interest Rate Risk  Purchasing Power Risk Unsystematic Risks (Diversifiable)  Business Risk  Financial risk
  • 14.
    Sources of Risk Market risk : variability in returns due to fluctuations in aggregate market  Recession, wars etc  Interest Rate Risk Interest risk refers to variability of total returns, particularly on fixed income securities due fluctuation in Interest rates.  Purchas Power or Inflation risk  when purchasing power declines.  Inflation also leads to hike in interest rates because lenders demand more to compensate themselves for loss in purchasing power
  • 15.
     Exchange risk= for international investors, a source of risk come from exchange rate fluctuation  Country Risk = For international investors, economic and political stability, law and order situation are important consideration in the investment decision Sources of Risk
  • 16.
    Interest rates andreturns  1. Increase in interest rates increases the required rate of return  RRR= Rf + Risk premium which reduces the prices of the securities (intrinsic value)  2. It increases cost of borrowing and hence cost of capital  3. It reduces money supply which lower demand for securities and resultantly prices fall. RRR Cashflow alueIntrinsicV + = 1
  • 17.
    Measuring Risk  Themost commonly used measure of risk for securities is standard deviation  SD measure the total risk of a security or a portfolio  It measure deviations of each observation from the arithmetic mean 1 ]R-[R 1 2 _ i − = ∑= n n i σ Measuring Risk
  • 18.
  • 19.
    Interpretation  The 5.89SD means that the security return can fluctuate between +/-5.89 from the mean value of 16%  More specifically, the return can fluctuate between 16 - 5.89 = 10.11 or 16 + 5.89 = 21.89 Your return could fall to as low as 10.11% or could rise to 21.89 %
  • 20.
    Realized Returns andrisk from Investing Class of assets Average SD S&P 500 Composite 9.21% 19.75% S&P Industrial 9.66 21.57 S&P Utility 8.47 20.54 Small Cap Stock (S&P 600) 14.82 37.23 AAA 20-year Corp Bond 3.87 10.05 US 15-year Bond 3.25 10.22 T-Bills 1.569 4.65