CUR 515 
Session 15 
The Reflective Teacher
There is one quality… 
…above all that makes a good teacher. It is the 
ability to reflect on what, why, and how we do 
things and to adapt and develop our practice 
throughout our careers.
Professional Reflection Is… 
• Deliberate 
• Purposeful 
• Structured 
• Focused on linking theory to 
practice 
• About learning, change and 
development
“Reflection is a form of mental processing that 
we use to fulfill a purpose or to achieve some 
anticipated outcome. It is applied to gain a 
better understanding of relatively complicated 
or unstructured ideas and is largely based on 
the reprocessing of knowledge, understanding, 
and emotions that we already possess.” 
–Jenny Moon, 2005
Reflection is 
developmental.
HHiitt && MMiissss 
Second 
Nature 
Relative 
Master 
Relative 
Master 
SStteeaaddyy 
II’’llll TTrryy 
HHeellpp!! 
Second 
Nature 
Reynold’s Model of Developing Competence, 
1965
UNCONSCIOUS 
COMPETENCE 
CONSCIOUS 
COMPETENCE 
CONSCIOUS 
INCOMPETENCE 
UNCONSCIOUS 
INCOMPETENCE 
UNCONSCIOUS 
INCOMPETENCE 
Skills have become 
“second nature” 
Using new skills and 
knowledge, carefully self-monitoring 
Becoming aware of 
what we don’t know or 
know how to do 
We don’t know what 
We don’t know what 
we don’t know 
we don’t know 
CONSCIOUS 
INCOMPETENCE 
Becoming aware of 
what we don’t know or 
know how to do 
CONSCIOUS 
COMPETENCE 
Using new skills and 
knowledge, carefully self-monitoring 
UNCONSCIOUS 
COMPETENCE 
Skills have become 
“second nature”
“Experts rely on a large repertoire of strategies 
and skills that they can call on automatically, 
leaving them free to deal with unique or 
unexpected events…” 
“The wealth of knowledge and routines that they 
employ, in fact, is so automatic that they often 
do not realize why they preferred a certain plan 
of action over another. However, when 
questioned, they are able to reconstruct the 
reasons for their decisions and behavior.” 
–Rollett, 2001
Reflection & Theory 
• Dewey (1933) believed that 
teachers must move from 
routine action to reflective 
action 
• He believed that reflection 
begins in a state of doubt or 
perplexity 
• Difficulty and uncertainty in 
practice are key moments for 
learning—> We can reflect on 
these problems to solve the 
perplexity and learn from them
Professional 
Developmen 
t 
Journal
Date 
Time 
Context 
Lesson name 
Critical 
incidents 
Initial feelings 
Reflection 
Analysis 
Evaluation 
Theory (if appropriate 
Any other thoughts 
Take aways, next steps
Critical 
Incidents
Effective Teaching Behaviors 
Rosenshine, 1971 
1. Introducing topics and activities clearly 
2. Explaining clearly with examples, other materials 
3. Systematic and serious organization of lessons 
4. Variety of teaching materials and methods 
5. Use of questions, especially higher order 
6. Use of praise and other reinforcement (non/verbal) 
7. Encouraging of learner participation 
8. Making use of learners’ ideas, clarifying and developing them 
9. Warmth, rapport and enthusiasm; mostly shown nonverbally
Top 5 Professional Qualities 
• Understanding and 
supportive 
• Committed, dedicated 
and hardworking 
• Fair with an inclusive 
and respectful 
approach 
• Warm 
• Humorous
Top 5 Teaching Skills 
• Clear instruction and 
presentation 
• Strong communication 
and active listening 
• Patience 
• Motivation and 
encouragement 
• Organization and 
classroom management
Top 5 Favorite Teacher 
Qualities 
• Sound subject knowledge 
• Understanding and gives 
great advice 
• Creative, interesting and 
imaginative 
• Warm and cheerful 
• Clear instructions and 
presentations 
Mentoring Towards Excellence, 2001

Session 15

  • 1.
    CUR 515 Session15 The Reflective Teacher
  • 3.
    There is onequality… …above all that makes a good teacher. It is the ability to reflect on what, why, and how we do things and to adapt and develop our practice throughout our careers.
  • 4.
    Professional Reflection Is… • Deliberate • Purposeful • Structured • Focused on linking theory to practice • About learning, change and development
  • 5.
    “Reflection is aform of mental processing that we use to fulfill a purpose or to achieve some anticipated outcome. It is applied to gain a better understanding of relatively complicated or unstructured ideas and is largely based on the reprocessing of knowledge, understanding, and emotions that we already possess.” –Jenny Moon, 2005
  • 6.
  • 7.
    HHiitt && MMiissss Second Nature Relative Master Relative Master SStteeaaddyy II’’llll TTrryy HHeellpp!! Second Nature Reynold’s Model of Developing Competence, 1965
  • 8.
    UNCONSCIOUS COMPETENCE CONSCIOUS COMPETENCE CONSCIOUS INCOMPETENCE UNCONSCIOUS INCOMPETENCE UNCONSCIOUS INCOMPETENCE Skills have become “second nature” Using new skills and knowledge, carefully self-monitoring Becoming aware of what we don’t know or know how to do We don’t know what We don’t know what we don’t know we don’t know CONSCIOUS INCOMPETENCE Becoming aware of what we don’t know or know how to do CONSCIOUS COMPETENCE Using new skills and knowledge, carefully self-monitoring UNCONSCIOUS COMPETENCE Skills have become “second nature”
  • 9.
    “Experts rely ona large repertoire of strategies and skills that they can call on automatically, leaving them free to deal with unique or unexpected events…” “The wealth of knowledge and routines that they employ, in fact, is so automatic that they often do not realize why they preferred a certain plan of action over another. However, when questioned, they are able to reconstruct the reasons for their decisions and behavior.” –Rollett, 2001
  • 11.
    Reflection & Theory • Dewey (1933) believed that teachers must move from routine action to reflective action • He believed that reflection begins in a state of doubt or perplexity • Difficulty and uncertainty in practice are key moments for learning—> We can reflect on these problems to solve the perplexity and learn from them
  • 12.
  • 13.
    Date Time Context Lesson name Critical incidents Initial feelings Reflection Analysis Evaluation Theory (if appropriate Any other thoughts Take aways, next steps
  • 14.
  • 16.
    Effective Teaching Behaviors Rosenshine, 1971 1. Introducing topics and activities clearly 2. Explaining clearly with examples, other materials 3. Systematic and serious organization of lessons 4. Variety of teaching materials and methods 5. Use of questions, especially higher order 6. Use of praise and other reinforcement (non/verbal) 7. Encouraging of learner participation 8. Making use of learners’ ideas, clarifying and developing them 9. Warmth, rapport and enthusiasm; mostly shown nonverbally
  • 17.
    Top 5 ProfessionalQualities • Understanding and supportive • Committed, dedicated and hardworking • Fair with an inclusive and respectful approach • Warm • Humorous
  • 18.
    Top 5 TeachingSkills • Clear instruction and presentation • Strong communication and active listening • Patience • Motivation and encouragement • Organization and classroom management
  • 19.
    Top 5 FavoriteTeacher Qualities • Sound subject knowledge • Understanding and gives great advice • Creative, interesting and imaginative • Warm and cheerful • Clear instructions and presentations Mentoring Towards Excellence, 2001