Peter Holten Mühlmann
@peter_holten
@trustpilot

Social Media Week Copenhagen – 20th February 2013 - Carlsberg
 Making shopping online more social
  and more

 120 employees, 26 nationalities



 Offices in CPH & NYC




                                       #smwtrust
#smwtrust
   Trust is the currency of the future
   The consumer perspective
   How to get social proof as a company
   The business case
   Dealing with the negative
   Customer focus
   #fail examples - you can’t cheat your way into trust


                                              #smwtrust
#smwtrust
6




 Think 2-5 years ahead. Now ask yourself these questions:

 Which consumer purchase decisions will not be based on
  other customers opinions?

 In which industries will companies be unaffected by their
  online reputation?




                                            #smwtrust
#smwtrust
1. Lots of people like this
       2. People like you like this
       3. Your friends like this
       4. You like this




                                                                                 #smwtrust
http://www.getelastic.com/the-5-dimensions-of-social-proof-on-ecommerce-sites/
#smwtrust
#smwtrust
#smwtrust
“75% of respondents would be deterred
from buying after reading 3 bad reviews.”
           (Lightspeed Research 2008)
#smwtrust
6 Million Customers Can’t be Wrong - Social Proof in the Buying Process
80% of consumers do research before buying




*Google / Ipsos Study 2012
                                                                   #smwtrust
6 Million Customers Can’t be Wrong - Social Proof in the Buying Process
6 Million Customers Can’t be Wrong - Social Proof in the Buying Process
1. Ask the crowd
           2. Encourage conversations
           3. Show off
           4. Use the negative




Source: Demandforce
                                                   #smwtrust
http://www.marketingtechblog.com/social-website/
Everybody is writing reviews

   47% of Britons have reviewed a product online *

Sharing positive experiences is reviewers main motivation**

   74% state that they write reviews because they want to share a good
    experience with other travellers
   78% state that they write reviews because they feel good about sharing useful
    information with other travelers


*Econsultancy, 2011
** Tripadvisor                                          #smwtrust
#smwtrust
Do’s
• Polite, simple, short message.
• Send invitation to review after package is received.
• Personalize & Include image of sender.

Dont’s
• Offer reward for good reviews.
• No other calls to action.
• No external links.
#smwtrust
#smwtrust
#smwtrust
#smwtrust
#smwtrust
• There can be many “right” solutions.
• Use A/B testing.
• Don’t compete with your own call to action
  buttons.
• External link to reviews on all pages, except
  checkout.
• Show that reviews are from a third party.
Version A: without reviews   Version B: with reviews




Test by mogens-moeller.dk/             #smwtrust
Version A: without reviews   Version B: with reviews




Test by mogens-moeller.dk/          #smwtrust
Version A: without Facebook   Version B: with Facebook




Test by mogens-moeller.dk/             #smwtrust
Version A: without Facebook   Version B: with Facebook




Test by mogens-moeller.dk/             #smwtrust
#smwtrust
#smwtrust
#smwtrust
• Most companies over-estimate the significance
                      of negative reviews.*
                    • Lack of negative reviews is perceived as
                      untrustworthy.*
                    • One negative review replied to properly is worth
                      10 good reviews.



* Forrester, 2010
•   A review is read around 8.6 times in average.
•   Reply in a polite & timely manner.
•   Continue issue resolution in private.
•   2/3 of consumers are happy to edit their review
    after issue resolution.
 “we found out that our Italian partner was no good”

 “we found out that our cancelation procedures needed to be
  fixed”




                                           #smwtrust
#smwtrust
#smwtrust
 Closed                       Open

   -   Not Transparent          -   Transparent
   -   Excluding                -   Participatory
   -   “owned” by companies     -   “owned” by consumers
   -   Communication            -   Conversation
   -   Reputation               -   Consumer Advice
       management


                                        #smwtrust
#smwtrust
#smwtrust
#smwtrust
#smwtrust
fToday, the rates of fake
                                 reviews range from about 2% up
                                           to about 6%.
                                      Cornell University 2012
By 2014, 10% to 15% of social
media reviews will be fake and
   paid for by companies.
        Gartner 2012




                                             #smwtrust
 Fact 1: 97% who made a purchase based on an online review
  found the review to be accurate (The Kelsey Group)

 Fact 2: Anyone can write a review on an open platform. Fake
  reviews happen.




                                          #smwtrust
 Fact 1: 10+ Full time employees at Trustpilot works with review
  quality on a daily basis

 Fact 2: Advance processes capture suspicious reviews on any
  major review site.
                                            Machine learning

                                   Clustering        Probability Models

                                       Behaviour Patterns
                                                Statistics



                                                   #smwtrust
 Fact 1: On Trustpilot reviews only get removed if they are fake
  or violating guidelines

 Fact 2: Companies can pay to automatically collect reviews
  from all customers

 Fact 3: Companies must follow service guidelines when
  collecting reviews

                                             #smwtrust
6 Million Customers Can’t be Wrong - Social Proof in the Buying Process
   Your consumers will talk about you whether you want it or not
   Reputation and credibility can’t be faked or bought – for long
   Markets are conversations – Engage!
   Any feedback, positive or negative, is good feedback
   Channel external feedback into your company culture
   You have a business case!




                                              #smwtrust
Thank you


@peter_holten
@trustpilot                 #smwtrust

More Related Content

PDF
The Story of Brand Attachment and Technology
PDF
Reality Check: How to build a real brand
PDF
20141119 la autoshow
PPTX
How to Use Trust to Exorcise Your Checkout Ghosts
PPT
Your Users Trust Each Other, Not You: Why and How to Implement Ratings and Re...
PPTX
Five types of companies that absolutely NEED to build trust to grow (but just...
PDF
TrustpilotB2BeGuide
PPTX
Gain, Maintain, and Retain: Why the future of your brand is powered by trust
The Story of Brand Attachment and Technology
Reality Check: How to build a real brand
20141119 la autoshow
How to Use Trust to Exorcise Your Checkout Ghosts
Your Users Trust Each Other, Not You: Why and How to Implement Ratings and Re...
Five types of companies that absolutely NEED to build trust to grow (but just...
TrustpilotB2BeGuide
Gain, Maintain, and Retain: Why the future of your brand is powered by trust

Similar to 6 Million Customers Can’t be Wrong - Social Proof in the Buying Process (20)

PPTX
Your Guide to Creating Engaging Social Media Content
PDF
Why Healthcare Marketing Must Go Social
PPTX
Turning Customer Reviews Into Real Revenue
PPTX
The 4 proven marketing systems every business must optimize to maximize reven...
PDF
The ultimate guide to online reviews
PPT
Techshare Presentation
PPTX
Social Media Bootcamp
PPT
Social Media In Financial Services Bt Tradespace
PPTX
Online Reviews & Reputation Management
PDF
Show me the sales! How social media impacts the bottom line
PPTX
Social Media BootCamp
PPTX
Online Reputation Management - 5 Ways To Manage Risk & Reward
PDF
Social Media Strategy And Metrics
PDF
iStrategy London - Social Commerce: Do Consumers Trust Your Brand? Steve Seme...
PDF
Enhancing Your Business With Social Media
PPTX
The Case For Reviews Webinar
PDF
Optimizing the Path to Conversion Leveraging Social Proof to Increase Sales
PDF
Social media doesn't drive sales. Or does it?
PPTX
Online marketing Best practices
PPTX
Tuck Symposium -- Social Media & Trust
Your Guide to Creating Engaging Social Media Content
Why Healthcare Marketing Must Go Social
Turning Customer Reviews Into Real Revenue
The 4 proven marketing systems every business must optimize to maximize reven...
The ultimate guide to online reviews
Techshare Presentation
Social Media Bootcamp
Social Media In Financial Services Bt Tradespace
Online Reviews & Reputation Management
Show me the sales! How social media impacts the bottom line
Social Media BootCamp
Online Reputation Management - 5 Ways To Manage Risk & Reward
Social Media Strategy And Metrics
iStrategy London - Social Commerce: Do Consumers Trust Your Brand? Steve Seme...
Enhancing Your Business With Social Media
The Case For Reviews Webinar
Optimizing the Path to Conversion Leveraging Social Proof to Increase Sales
Social media doesn't drive sales. Or does it?
Online marketing Best practices
Tuck Symposium -- Social Media & Trust
Ad

More from Trustpilot (20)

PPTX
Outperform your competition with Customer Engagement
PPTX
6 Ways to use Behavioural Psychology to Drive Conversions & Grow Revenue
PPTX
How to Make Customer Satisfaction Your Key Differentiator
PPTX
The 2017 eCommerce Marketer's Virtual Summit - Optimizing Your Key Conversion...
PPTX
Trustpilot + Google
PPTX
Trustpilot præsentation fra Søren Sieg Jensen, Cykelpartner
PPTX
Email Marketing + Social Proof = The Perfect Formula to Convert More Browsers...
PPTX
Reviews: The Best Kept Secret to Landing Page Optimization
PPTX
Google &Reviews: Everything you need to know
PPTX
Trustpilot’s Tips On Making The Festive Season Pay-Off All Year
PPTX
Vertrauen als Schlüssel zu einer höheren Conversion-Rate
PPTX
5 Health Checks for Managing Customer Retention
PPTX
From SLANDER to CANDOR: 10 Steps to Get Started with Reputation Management To...
PPTX
7 Tactics to Turbo-Charge Your Search Programs Using Customer Reviews
PPTX
Driving Lifelong Customer Devotion With Loyalty Campaigns Confirmation
PPTX
What's New at Trustpilot? Product Reviews
PPTX
Leveraging Customer Reviews to Boost Performance & Efficiency in PPC Channels
PPTX
IRCE Thriftbooks Trustpilot presentation
PPTX
Using Trust to Propel the Buyer Journey
PPTX
How StorageMart Succeeds in Global & Local Search
Outperform your competition with Customer Engagement
6 Ways to use Behavioural Psychology to Drive Conversions & Grow Revenue
How to Make Customer Satisfaction Your Key Differentiator
The 2017 eCommerce Marketer's Virtual Summit - Optimizing Your Key Conversion...
Trustpilot + Google
Trustpilot præsentation fra Søren Sieg Jensen, Cykelpartner
Email Marketing + Social Proof = The Perfect Formula to Convert More Browsers...
Reviews: The Best Kept Secret to Landing Page Optimization
Google &Reviews: Everything you need to know
Trustpilot’s Tips On Making The Festive Season Pay-Off All Year
Vertrauen als Schlüssel zu einer höheren Conversion-Rate
5 Health Checks for Managing Customer Retention
From SLANDER to CANDOR: 10 Steps to Get Started with Reputation Management To...
7 Tactics to Turbo-Charge Your Search Programs Using Customer Reviews
Driving Lifelong Customer Devotion With Loyalty Campaigns Confirmation
What's New at Trustpilot? Product Reviews
Leveraging Customer Reviews to Boost Performance & Efficiency in PPC Channels
IRCE Thriftbooks Trustpilot presentation
Using Trust to Propel the Buyer Journey
How StorageMart Succeeds in Global & Local Search
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

DOCX
Center Enamel Enabling Precision and Sustainability in the Netherlands' Advan...
PPTX
Warehouse. B pptx
PDF
The Relationship between Leadership Behaviourand Firm Performance in the Read...
PDF
IFRS Green Book_Part B for professional pdf
PPTX
PPT Hafizullah Oria- Final Thesis Exam.pptx
PPTX
Hospitality & tourism management.pptxHospitality & tourism management.pptx
PDF
The Dynamic CLOs Shaping the Future of the Legal Industry in 2025.pdf
DOCX
Handbook of entrepreneurship- Chapter 10 - Feasibility analysis by Subin K Mohan
PDF
BeMetals_Presentation_September_2025.pdf
PDF
The Impact of Historical Events on Legal Communication Styles (www.kiu.ac.ug)
PDF
France's Top 5 Promising EdTech Companies to Watch in 2025.pdf
PDF
Implementing Steam Education: Challenges and Solutions (www.kiu.ac.ug)
PPTX
Biomass_Energy_PPT_FIN AL________________.pptx
PDF
How to run a consulting project from scratch
PPTX
1. Ancient Civilization presentations .pptx
PPTX
TS - CIM-as of august 2023 .pptx
PPTX
Capital Investment in IS Infrastracture and Innovation (SDG9)
PPTX
OS ALL UNITS MATxtdtc5ctc5cycgctERIAL.pptx
PDF
COVID-19 Primer for business case prep.pdf
PDF
Shriram Finance, one of India's leading financial services companies, which o...
Center Enamel Enabling Precision and Sustainability in the Netherlands' Advan...
Warehouse. B pptx
The Relationship between Leadership Behaviourand Firm Performance in the Read...
IFRS Green Book_Part B for professional pdf
PPT Hafizullah Oria- Final Thesis Exam.pptx
Hospitality & tourism management.pptxHospitality & tourism management.pptx
The Dynamic CLOs Shaping the Future of the Legal Industry in 2025.pdf
Handbook of entrepreneurship- Chapter 10 - Feasibility analysis by Subin K Mohan
BeMetals_Presentation_September_2025.pdf
The Impact of Historical Events on Legal Communication Styles (www.kiu.ac.ug)
France's Top 5 Promising EdTech Companies to Watch in 2025.pdf
Implementing Steam Education: Challenges and Solutions (www.kiu.ac.ug)
Biomass_Energy_PPT_FIN AL________________.pptx
How to run a consulting project from scratch
1. Ancient Civilization presentations .pptx
TS - CIM-as of august 2023 .pptx
Capital Investment in IS Infrastracture and Innovation (SDG9)
OS ALL UNITS MATxtdtc5ctc5cycgctERIAL.pptx
COVID-19 Primer for business case prep.pdf
Shriram Finance, one of India's leading financial services companies, which o...

6 Million Customers Can’t be Wrong - Social Proof in the Buying Process

  • 1. Peter Holten Mühlmann @peter_holten @trustpilot Social Media Week Copenhagen – 20th February 2013 - Carlsberg
  • 2.  Making shopping online more social and more  120 employees, 26 nationalities  Offices in CPH & NYC #smwtrust
  • 4. Trust is the currency of the future  The consumer perspective  How to get social proof as a company  The business case  Dealing with the negative  Customer focus  #fail examples - you can’t cheat your way into trust #smwtrust
  • 6. 6  Think 2-5 years ahead. Now ask yourself these questions:  Which consumer purchase decisions will not be based on other customers opinions?  In which industries will companies be unaffected by their online reputation? #smwtrust
  • 8. 1. Lots of people like this 2. People like you like this 3. Your friends like this 4. You like this #smwtrust http://www.getelastic.com/the-5-dimensions-of-social-proof-on-ecommerce-sites/
  • 12. “75% of respondents would be deterred from buying after reading 3 bad reviews.” (Lightspeed Research 2008)
  • 15. 80% of consumers do research before buying *Google / Ipsos Study 2012 #smwtrust
  • 18. 1. Ask the crowd 2. Encourage conversations 3. Show off 4. Use the negative Source: Demandforce #smwtrust http://www.marketingtechblog.com/social-website/
  • 19. Everybody is writing reviews  47% of Britons have reviewed a product online * Sharing positive experiences is reviewers main motivation**  74% state that they write reviews because they want to share a good experience with other travellers  78% state that they write reviews because they feel good about sharing useful information with other travelers *Econsultancy, 2011 ** Tripadvisor #smwtrust
  • 21. Do’s • Polite, simple, short message. • Send invitation to review after package is received. • Personalize & Include image of sender. Dont’s • Offer reward for good reviews. • No other calls to action. • No external links.
  • 27. • There can be many “right” solutions. • Use A/B testing. • Don’t compete with your own call to action buttons. • External link to reviews on all pages, except checkout. • Show that reviews are from a third party.
  • 28. Version A: without reviews Version B: with reviews Test by mogens-moeller.dk/ #smwtrust
  • 29. Version A: without reviews Version B: with reviews Test by mogens-moeller.dk/ #smwtrust
  • 30. Version A: without Facebook Version B: with Facebook Test by mogens-moeller.dk/ #smwtrust
  • 31. Version A: without Facebook Version B: with Facebook Test by mogens-moeller.dk/ #smwtrust
  • 35. • Most companies over-estimate the significance of negative reviews.* • Lack of negative reviews is perceived as untrustworthy.* • One negative review replied to properly is worth 10 good reviews. * Forrester, 2010
  • 36. A review is read around 8.6 times in average. • Reply in a polite & timely manner. • Continue issue resolution in private. • 2/3 of consumers are happy to edit their review after issue resolution.
  • 37.  “we found out that our Italian partner was no good”  “we found out that our cancelation procedures needed to be fixed” #smwtrust
  • 40.  Closed  Open - Not Transparent - Transparent - Excluding - Participatory - “owned” by companies - “owned” by consumers - Communication - Conversation - Reputation - Consumer Advice management #smwtrust
  • 45. fToday, the rates of fake reviews range from about 2% up to about 6%. Cornell University 2012 By 2014, 10% to 15% of social media reviews will be fake and paid for by companies. Gartner 2012 #smwtrust
  • 46.  Fact 1: 97% who made a purchase based on an online review found the review to be accurate (The Kelsey Group)  Fact 2: Anyone can write a review on an open platform. Fake reviews happen. #smwtrust
  • 47.  Fact 1: 10+ Full time employees at Trustpilot works with review quality on a daily basis  Fact 2: Advance processes capture suspicious reviews on any major review site. Machine learning Clustering Probability Models Behaviour Patterns Statistics #smwtrust
  • 48.  Fact 1: On Trustpilot reviews only get removed if they are fake or violating guidelines  Fact 2: Companies can pay to automatically collect reviews from all customers  Fact 3: Companies must follow service guidelines when collecting reviews #smwtrust
  • 50. Your consumers will talk about you whether you want it or not  Reputation and credibility can’t be faked or bought – for long  Markets are conversations – Engage!  Any feedback, positive or negative, is good feedback  Channel external feedback into your company culture  You have a business case! #smwtrust

Editor's Notes

  • #6: What I (we) believe inExamples:AirBnB, Taskrabbit, Fiverr, elance, car sharing, bike rental systems in big citiesKickstarter.com projects are great examples of trust in businessOr the Phone box changed into free libraries >> http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-derbyshire-16364652We share info with each other (facebook login) we trust companies Trust is about building relationships, dialogue, ask questions, give answers, gain feedback from one to another etc.DK the country with the highest level of trust: maybe it all starts from here?
  • #8: Facebook likes & reviewsIt can be a shop displaying “sold out” under items - increases the sense of urgencyHow many people bought it “The concept of social proof says that people are more likely to do business with you if there are clear indicators that other people are also doing business with you (and that doing business with you is safe)”
  • #9: The closer you get, the more important it is
  • #12: Experts are still valued, but can easily be “bought” a
  • #14: So the number of webshops is explodingThere is a bigger need for navigate tools in this worldUsers are the best experts when it comes to online shopping as tehre are many small niche players who go after the long tails, like gantsblancs.fr, only seelingwhitye gloves and doing a great job at itOnline influenced offline sales
  • #16: Consumers are more shopping savvy than ever, From price comparison websitesTo scanning their social network for recommandationsFrom geotargeted search (foursquare, yelp)To mobile commerce – check online what’s available offline etcThe typical customer journey is complex and needs real engegement in order to gain loyalty
  • #22: This is not marketingThis is you wanting feedback
  • #24: Infographic: http://www.digitalbuzzblog.com/infographic-the-psychology-of-social-commerce/In our head, it works like this: “If all these people is doing it, this must be good“.
  • #29: An Independent conversion expert made a split test about the effect of social proof in the buying process
  • #30: Why such a big difference?Positive customer reviews usually have a big effect when a potential customer needs to evaluate whether or not he dares to buy in a relatively unknown shop.It makes you feel less lonely in a webshop – you can see others have been before you.
  • #31: An Independent conversion expert made a split test about the effect of social proof in the buying process – her an example with Facebook “fans” at the bottom of the page
  • #32: An Independent conversion expert made a split test about the effect of social proof in the buying process – her an example with Facebook “fans” at the bottom of the page
  • #35: The wisdom of the crowd never liesDiscussion blossom on brands on social mediaTrustpilot reviews can is the social proof to their discussions.
  • #36: “Single bad reviews”
  • #37: Unless the review is extreme or threatening, just reply.
  • #39: and can be used for engaging with other customers, for marketing purposesGives them something to talk about
  • #41: Great ending – summary – world is going from closed to open…Open however also means, can be manipulated…That is the one weakness.
  • #43: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=phaAO-3Dfak
  • #45: You can fool all the people some of the time and some of the people all of the time, but you cannot fool all the people all the time." 
  • #50: Quality over anonymity People complain about facebook…