Social and Political
    Marketing



  Iwan Budhiarta
Social Marketing
First introduced in 1970
Defined as the use of marketing
principles and techniques to influence
the acceptance of a social idea for the
benefit of individuals, groups, or society.
Rooted in both commercial and social
reform campaigns
Health Campaigns and
  Social Marketing
Public Health Campaigns
 Strategic   campaigns designed:
   to promote healthy behaviors
   to discourage unhealthy behaviors

Social Marketing Campaigns
 Campaigns     for social improvement
Public Information Campaigns
 Dissemination   of information
Anti-Smoking
Social Marketing
       Principles
Concepts and principles of strategic
communication campaigns (Ad/PR)
Strategic campaigns designed to:
 spread  knowledge
 change attitudes

 alter behaviors

 spreading messages of social change
Social Marketing
   Principles (contd.)
Value-laden activities
 Engineering     social change
    Decisions   about what is good and bad
Conflicts of interests
 E.g.,   anti-smoking from Phillip Morris
Tension between:
 Social   good and individual freedoms
Social vs. commercial
       marketing campaigns
                                          Commercial
                    Social Marketing
                                          Marketing
Amount of change    Large proportion of   Small shifts in
expected            population            market share
Time frame of
                    Delayed / Probable    Instant gratification
expected benefits
                                          Lots of scope for
Presentation        Cannot be hyped
                                          window dressing
Available budget    Miniscule             Massive
                                          Formative and
Evaluation          Primarily summative
                                          summative
The 7 P’s of
      social marketing
Product: Tangible, physical products (e.g. condoms)
services (e.g. medical exams), practices (e.g. drunk
driving), or intangible ideas (e.g. global poverty)
Price: Monetary, opportunity cost, contribution
Place: Retailer, doctor’s office, mass media
Promotion: Integrated use of advertising, PR,
promotion, media advocacy, personal selling
Partnership: Work with other groups to max effects
Policy: Work with policy to capitalize on laws
Politics: Work with politicians to change policy
Communication objectives

Perception: Create awareness, interest, excitement

Retention: Recall and recognition of message

Cognition: Comprehend benefits in message

Attitude: Positive disposition, attribute evaluation,
argument acceptance, reevaluation of current attitude

Behavior: Stimulate inquiries, discussion, behavior
Successful social
marketing campaigns
Success is subjective and case-specific
Goals should be SMART:
 Specific
 Measurable
 Attainable
 Realistic
 Time-limited

Types of evaluation:
 Knowledge gain
 Attitude change
 Behavioral indicators
Advantages of Social
Marketing Campaigns
Legitimate source
 Government,  non-profits
 No obvious self-interest

Social desirability of change
Problems with Social
Marketing Campaigns
Faulty assumptions
   Change is not simply a function of spreading
    information; social norms, engrained behaviors
Lack of adequate resources
Psychological resistance
 Discounting the message and/or source
 Immunity perceptions
 Inability to change habitual behaviors
Election Campaigns
Candidate elections
 President and Congress, State Executives and
  Legislatures, Local Mayoral and Council Seats
 Decline of political parties - Independents

Issue referenda
 Public decisions about issues
 Increased lobbying of politicians through media

Costs have exploded
Political Advertising
Key means of communication with public
Advertising spending accounts for majority of
campaign budgets, especially for presidency
   750,000 spots aired in ‘04 presidential race
   Concentrated on 1/3 of population
        battleground states, battleground markets
Lessons for Campaigning
Issue ownership and valence issues
Elections are won locally
Candidates don’t control dialogue
Worst inaccuracies on Internet, radio,
and direct mail - less gatekeeping
Five things to watch in
    Ad Composition
Importance of non-verbal cues
Sounds and music sets tones
Graphics
Editing
Code words
Political Action Committees
  Ads by parties, groups, and individuals
   Parties    outspend candidates in 2000
  Broadens strategic options
   Good     cop/Bad cop
      Use    third parties to deliver the negative
   Stealth    strategies
      Hidebehind indecipherable names
      Go negative while shielding self
Advertising Effects
Ads have effects
   Drive news reporting
        739 airings of Swift Boat Ads in
         three states drove coverage
        Ads also dictate the issue agenda
   Influence voters’ attitudes
        Shape perceptions of candidates
        Provide information about positions
Highly Controversial

Question quality and accuracy of info
 Mudslinging   and misrepresentations
Fear about impact on citizens
 Fosters   cynicism and demobilization
Distort opinions and alter elections
 Switching   vote based on ad claims
Lessons from Modern
     Campaigning
Candidates don’t dictate the news discourse
   Though gatekeepers sometimes let them
Campaigns do control websites, broadcast ads &
direct media (mailers, telephone calls, etc.)
   Can amplify inaccuracies and distortions
Elections are won locally - ex. electoral college
   Swing states, specific regions, local precincts
Play good cop, bad cop - makes attacks worse
Negative Advertising
Not a new occurrence – since the 50s
Important part of recent election bids
Negative Ads
Focus on criticisms of the opponent, fault
character, accomplishments, or issue positions –
“attack advertising”
Often come from outside campaign
Still, negative ads are a minority
   Most are contrast ads or positive ads
Comparative Ads

Contrast the sponsoring candidate with
opponent on issue positions or character
Types of Positive Ads


Positive Ads – focus on good characteristics,
accomplishments, or issue positions of sponsor
Image Oriented – focus on character and personal traits
Issue Oriented – focus on the issue/policy positions
Examples of Ethnic Appeals

  Segmented targeting of ethnic groups
  Typically appeal in native language




        Doesn’t always work so well
Political Ad Effects
The Negativity Effect
 Negative   Ads are more easily recalled

The “Demobilizing” Effect
 Negative   ads are mobilizing

The Backlash Effect
 May   actually strengthen resolve to vote

Social and Political Marketing

  • 1.
    Social and Political Marketing Iwan Budhiarta
  • 2.
    Social Marketing First introducedin 1970 Defined as the use of marketing principles and techniques to influence the acceptance of a social idea for the benefit of individuals, groups, or society. Rooted in both commercial and social reform campaigns
  • 3.
    Health Campaigns and Social Marketing Public Health Campaigns  Strategic campaigns designed:  to promote healthy behaviors  to discourage unhealthy behaviors Social Marketing Campaigns  Campaigns for social improvement Public Information Campaigns  Dissemination of information
  • 4.
  • 5.
    Social Marketing Principles Concepts and principles of strategic communication campaigns (Ad/PR) Strategic campaigns designed to:  spread knowledge  change attitudes  alter behaviors  spreading messages of social change
  • 6.
    Social Marketing Principles (contd.) Value-laden activities  Engineering social change  Decisions about what is good and bad Conflicts of interests  E.g., anti-smoking from Phillip Morris Tension between:  Social good and individual freedoms
  • 7.
    Social vs. commercial marketing campaigns Commercial Social Marketing Marketing Amount of change Large proportion of Small shifts in expected population market share Time frame of Delayed / Probable Instant gratification expected benefits Lots of scope for Presentation Cannot be hyped window dressing Available budget Miniscule Massive Formative and Evaluation Primarily summative summative
  • 8.
    The 7 P’sof social marketing Product: Tangible, physical products (e.g. condoms) services (e.g. medical exams), practices (e.g. drunk driving), or intangible ideas (e.g. global poverty) Price: Monetary, opportunity cost, contribution Place: Retailer, doctor’s office, mass media Promotion: Integrated use of advertising, PR, promotion, media advocacy, personal selling Partnership: Work with other groups to max effects Policy: Work with policy to capitalize on laws Politics: Work with politicians to change policy
  • 9.
    Communication objectives Perception: Createawareness, interest, excitement Retention: Recall and recognition of message Cognition: Comprehend benefits in message Attitude: Positive disposition, attribute evaluation, argument acceptance, reevaluation of current attitude Behavior: Stimulate inquiries, discussion, behavior
  • 10.
    Successful social marketing campaigns Successis subjective and case-specific Goals should be SMART:  Specific  Measurable  Attainable  Realistic  Time-limited Types of evaluation:  Knowledge gain  Attitude change  Behavioral indicators
  • 11.
    Advantages of Social MarketingCampaigns Legitimate source  Government, non-profits  No obvious self-interest Social desirability of change
  • 12.
    Problems with Social MarketingCampaigns Faulty assumptions  Change is not simply a function of spreading information; social norms, engrained behaviors Lack of adequate resources Psychological resistance  Discounting the message and/or source  Immunity perceptions  Inability to change habitual behaviors
  • 13.
    Election Campaigns Candidate elections President and Congress, State Executives and Legislatures, Local Mayoral and Council Seats  Decline of political parties - Independents Issue referenda  Public decisions about issues  Increased lobbying of politicians through media Costs have exploded
  • 14.
    Political Advertising Key meansof communication with public Advertising spending accounts for majority of campaign budgets, especially for presidency  750,000 spots aired in ‘04 presidential race  Concentrated on 1/3 of population  battleground states, battleground markets
  • 15.
    Lessons for Campaigning Issueownership and valence issues Elections are won locally Candidates don’t control dialogue Worst inaccuracies on Internet, radio, and direct mail - less gatekeeping
  • 16.
    Five things towatch in Ad Composition Importance of non-verbal cues Sounds and music sets tones Graphics Editing Code words
  • 17.
    Political Action Committees Ads by parties, groups, and individuals  Parties outspend candidates in 2000 Broadens strategic options  Good cop/Bad cop  Use third parties to deliver the negative  Stealth strategies  Hidebehind indecipherable names  Go negative while shielding self
  • 18.
    Advertising Effects Ads haveeffects  Drive news reporting  739 airings of Swift Boat Ads in three states drove coverage  Ads also dictate the issue agenda  Influence voters’ attitudes  Shape perceptions of candidates  Provide information about positions
  • 19.
    Highly Controversial Question qualityand accuracy of info  Mudslinging and misrepresentations Fear about impact on citizens  Fosters cynicism and demobilization Distort opinions and alter elections  Switching vote based on ad claims
  • 20.
    Lessons from Modern Campaigning Candidates don’t dictate the news discourse  Though gatekeepers sometimes let them Campaigns do control websites, broadcast ads & direct media (mailers, telephone calls, etc.)  Can amplify inaccuracies and distortions Elections are won locally - ex. electoral college  Swing states, specific regions, local precincts Play good cop, bad cop - makes attacks worse
  • 21.
    Negative Advertising Not anew occurrence – since the 50s Important part of recent election bids
  • 22.
    Negative Ads Focus oncriticisms of the opponent, fault character, accomplishments, or issue positions – “attack advertising” Often come from outside campaign Still, negative ads are a minority  Most are contrast ads or positive ads
  • 23.
    Comparative Ads Contrast thesponsoring candidate with opponent on issue positions or character
  • 24.
    Types of PositiveAds Positive Ads – focus on good characteristics, accomplishments, or issue positions of sponsor Image Oriented – focus on character and personal traits Issue Oriented – focus on the issue/policy positions
  • 25.
    Examples of EthnicAppeals Segmented targeting of ethnic groups Typically appeal in native language Doesn’t always work so well
  • 26.
    Political Ad Effects TheNegativity Effect  Negative Ads are more easily recalled The “Demobilizing” Effect  Negative ads are mobilizing The Backlash Effect  May actually strengthen resolve to vote