Stop the Financial Bleed: Triaging the
Costs of Hospital-Based Physician
Services
October 2018
Agenda
§ Host introductions
§ Hospital-based arrangements:
§ The basics
§ Payment mechanisms
§ Key considerations and best practices
§ Case study
2
Your Hosts
Luis Argueso
§ 10+ years of valuation
experience with hospital-based
service arrangements
§ Author of numerous articles on
fair market value, commercial
reasonableness, compensation
trends, and telemedicine
§ Consulting experience with
hospitals and provider groups
regarding hospital-based
service lines
Allison Pullins
§ 6+ years on the leadership team
at MD Ranger; 12+ years of
industry experience
§ Helped hundreds of hospitals
use market benchmarks and
tools to enhance their physician
contracting programs
§ Hosted 55+ webinars on
physician services, FMV
documentation, compliance best
practices, and more
3
Stephanie Tafoya
§ 2+ years of compensation
valuation experience
§ Prior to working on valuations,
5 years of experience
managing physician
compensation survey data at
MGMA
§ Author of articles
demonstrating proper use of
benchmark data
THE BASICS
4
Common and Emerging Specialties
§ Anesthesia
§ Critical care/Intensivists
§ Emergency Medicine
§ Hospitalists
§ General Hospitalists
§ OB Hospitalists (aka “Laborists”)
§ Psychiatric Hospitalists
§ Pediatric Hospitalists
§ Orthopedic Hospitalists
§ Surgical Hospitalists (aka “Surgicalists”)
§ Neonatology
§ Pathology
§ Radiology
§ Trauma
5
Growth Demonstrated in Benchmarks
6
Source: MD Ranger
Financial Assistance Needed
§ Sometimes professional services
revenue insufficient
§ Why?
§ Payor mix
§ Coverage requirements
§ Volume
§ Specialty
§ Market factors
7
Hospital-Based Arrangements Grow in
Scope
8
§ MD Ranger tracks
hospitals’ spending on
physician contracts in
aggregate
§ Over the past three
years, we’ve seen
growth in hospital
spending for these
types of services
Source: MD Ranger
When You’ve Seen One, You’ve Seen
Only One
§ Each hospital
arrangement is unique
§ Benchmarks can be
guideposts
§ Careful analysis needed
for all hospital-based
arrangements
9
Key Trends
§ Ever-increasing costs due to reduced
volumes
§ Higher demand for services
§ Continued bifurcation of hospital-based
“versus” office-based physicians
§ Specialty hospitalist services
10
PAYMENT MECHANISMS
11
Subsidies
§ Cost of the services exceed
the anticipated professional
revenue
§ Provider bills and collects
§ Flat payment is negotiated
§ Market benchmarks are
available
12
Source: MD Ranger 2018 Reports
Collection Guarantees
§ Cost of the services exceed the anticipated professional revenue
§ Also known as a “Revenue Guarantee”
§ Provider bills and collects
§ Flat payments are occasionally made
§ Parties meet regularly to reconcile the practice’s revenue against the guarantee
amount
§ Hospital pays for remaining shortfall or practice refunds the excess
13
Cost to Provide Services
Payment
Professional Collections
Payment Mechanisms by Service
14
Source: MD Ranger 2018 Reports
Call Coverage Payments on the Rise
15
Source: MD Ranger
KEY CONSIDERATIONS
AND BEST PRACTICES
16
Staffing
§ Is proposed staffing level
reasonable?
§ Look at time requirements,
production levels
§ Note: physician-only staffing
will likely result in fewer FTE’s
but higher costs
§ Heavy on APPs? Costs could
decrease
17
Provider Compensation
§ Primary cost-driver
§ Keep in mind:
§ Location
§ Recruitment challenges?
§ On-call coverage issues?
§ Production levels?
§ Visit www.hcfmv.com for
Stephanie’s insights regarding the
nuances of compensation
benchmarking
18
Run to Benchmarks
§ Market benchmarks are available for total annual payments in
hospital based arrangements
§ Benchmarks are useful to understand where your agreement
payment falls relative to other arrangements in the specialty
§ Use benchmarks with great care
19
Operating Expenses
§ Billing and collecting expenses
§ Malpractice
§ Legal, accounting
§ Taxes
§ Insurance
§ Miscellaneous
20
Expertise in Marketplace & FMV
21
§ Your organization should have access to
experts who:
§ Know and understand hospital-based
service arrangements
§ Understand your organization’s profile
(AMC? Critical access?)
§ Latest trends in hospital-based service
lines
§ FMV and commercial reasonableness
§ Don’t have such expertise internally? Hire a
consultant who can help
CASE STUDY:
EMERGENCY MEDICINE
AT SYCAMORE
HOSPITAL*
22
*pseudonym
Reimbursement Changes Prompt
Renegotiation
§ Physician group expects reduction in commercial payor revenue
§ Hospital and physician group need to negotiate new agreement
§ Hospital embarks on analysis of service line
23
Sources of Revenue Analysis
§ Payor mix comparison
§ Collections per visit comparison
§ Collections per wRVU
24
HCUP EM “Poor” Payor %: 45.7%
HCUP Benchmark Payor Mix
Efficiency Analysis
§ Throughput comparison
§ w/RVUs per hour
§ Measure ED acuity
25
Key Take-Aways
26
Review Market Data
•MD Ranger
•Compensation surveys
•Specialty-specific resources
Understand Agreement Terms
•Service Level
•Payment Mechanism
Perform Expert Analysis
•Staffing
•Operating Expenses
•Benchmarking
Need support?
§ Contact us with questions
§ Download resources on
www.mdranger.com or
www.hcfmv.com
§ Follow us on social
27

More Related Content

PDF
Physician Contract Compliance Risks
PPTX
FAIR MARKET VALUE & COMMERCIAL REASONABLENESS
PPTX
Too Many Medical Directors?
PPTX
Uncovering Red Flags in Physician Contracts
PDF
Compliance Pitfalls of Hospital-Based Contracts
PDF
Commercial Reasonableness: What You Must Know Before Contracting with Physic...
PDF
Professional Services Agreement: An Alternative Strategy to Hospital Employment
PPTX
Determining Value & Physician Compensation When Purchasing a Practice
Physician Contract Compliance Risks
FAIR MARKET VALUE & COMMERCIAL REASONABLENESS
Too Many Medical Directors?
Uncovering Red Flags in Physician Contracts
Compliance Pitfalls of Hospital-Based Contracts
Commercial Reasonableness: What You Must Know Before Contracting with Physic...
Professional Services Agreement: An Alternative Strategy to Hospital Employment
Determining Value & Physician Compensation When Purchasing a Practice

What's hot (20)

DOCX
Melonie L Henderson Resume 03092016 (1)
PPTX
PYA Presentation: “Thorny Issues in FMV and Commercial Reasonableness"
PDF
Revenue Optimization
PDF
Defining, Determining, and Documenting FMV
PDF
Best Practices for Physician Call Coverage Compensation
PPTX
Practice Valuation & Physician Compensation Planning Considerations
PPTX
Current Issues in Healthcare Valuation
PPT
Valuing Oncology Transactions
PPTX
Everything You Must Know About Physician Emergency Call Coverage
PDF
Navigating Medical Staff Officer and Physician Leadership Compensation
PDF
5 Mistakes Hospitals Make with Call Coverage Agreements
PPTX
Roadmap for Physician Contracting: Setting Up for Success in 2017
PPT
Both prioritization and review production should be centralized
DOCX
M Henderson Resume
PPTX
Hot Valuation Issues for Physician Agreements
PPTX
Exploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible Assets
PPTX
Improving Hospital Revenue
PPTX
Hot Topics in Physician Compensation
PDF
Physician Contracting for Exceptional Hospitals
PPTX
Presentation Uncovers Trends in the Unpredictable Healthcare Industry
Melonie L Henderson Resume 03092016 (1)
PYA Presentation: “Thorny Issues in FMV and Commercial Reasonableness"
Revenue Optimization
Defining, Determining, and Documenting FMV
Best Practices for Physician Call Coverage Compensation
Practice Valuation & Physician Compensation Planning Considerations
Current Issues in Healthcare Valuation
Valuing Oncology Transactions
Everything You Must Know About Physician Emergency Call Coverage
Navigating Medical Staff Officer and Physician Leadership Compensation
5 Mistakes Hospitals Make with Call Coverage Agreements
Roadmap for Physician Contracting: Setting Up for Success in 2017
Both prioritization and review production should be centralized
M Henderson Resume
Hot Valuation Issues for Physician Agreements
Exploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible Assets
Improving Hospital Revenue
Hot Topics in Physician Compensation
Physician Contracting for Exceptional Hospitals
Presentation Uncovers Trends in the Unpredictable Healthcare Industry

Similar to Stop the Financial Bleed: Triaging the Cost of Hospital-Based Physician Services (20)

PDF
Defining, Determining, and Documenting FMV
PDF
Key Findings from MD Ranger's 2018 Total Facility Benchmarks Report
PDF
Physician Contracting Whack-A-Mole: Playing to Win
PDF
Key Findings from Facility Totals Reports 2017
PPTX
Key Findings from MD Ranger's 2017 Facility Totals Benchmarks
PPT
Fundamentals of Healthcare Valuation
PDF
Key Trends in ASC Valuations: Benchmark and use common valuation methodologies
PDF
What You MUST Know About Compensating Physician Emergency Coverage
PPTX
Looking Ahead to Physician Contracting in 2018
PDF
Navigating Hospital-Based Contracts
PDF
Nobilis health corporate presentation march 3.23.18 final[2]
PDF
10th Anniversary Webinar Series: The Definitive Guide to Medical Directorships
PDF
Stacking Physician Agreements: Identifying and Mitigating Risks
PDF
Key Strategies for Compensating Physician Administrative Positions
PDF
Measuring the Financial Health of Your Physician Contracting Program
PDF
Limitations of Market Data
PPTX
Overcoming Physician Contracting Challenges with MD Ranger
PDF
7 Signs Your Organization Could Have Risky Contracts
PPTX
Hospital-Owned Orthopaedic Practices
PDF
Key Findings from Facility Totals Reports 2017
Defining, Determining, and Documenting FMV
Key Findings from MD Ranger's 2018 Total Facility Benchmarks Report
Physician Contracting Whack-A-Mole: Playing to Win
Key Findings from Facility Totals Reports 2017
Key Findings from MD Ranger's 2017 Facility Totals Benchmarks
Fundamentals of Healthcare Valuation
Key Trends in ASC Valuations: Benchmark and use common valuation methodologies
What You MUST Know About Compensating Physician Emergency Coverage
Looking Ahead to Physician Contracting in 2018
Navigating Hospital-Based Contracts
Nobilis health corporate presentation march 3.23.18 final[2]
10th Anniversary Webinar Series: The Definitive Guide to Medical Directorships
Stacking Physician Agreements: Identifying and Mitigating Risks
Key Strategies for Compensating Physician Administrative Positions
Measuring the Financial Health of Your Physician Contracting Program
Limitations of Market Data
Overcoming Physician Contracting Challenges with MD Ranger
7 Signs Your Organization Could Have Risky Contracts
Hospital-Owned Orthopaedic Practices
Key Findings from Facility Totals Reports 2017

More from MD Ranger, Inc. (20)

PPTX
Key Findings from MD Ranger’s 2020 Facility Totals Benchmarks
PPTX
10th Anniversary Webinar Series: The Definitive Guide to Emergency Call Coverage
PPTX
Compliance and Legal Risks in Laborist, Surgicalist, and Hospitalist Arrangem...
PDF
Audit Physician Contracts the Smart Way
PDF
Outside of FMV Range? Now What?
PDF
What You Need to Know from HCCA's 2019 Compliance Institute
PDF
Perfecting Your Physician Contracting Program
PDF
Uncovering Best Practices from Corporate Integrity Agreements
PDF
Physician Contracting at Small and Rural Hospitals
PPTX
Stark Law Basics
PDF
What to Do When You're Out of FMV Range
PDF
Auditing Physician Contracts with MD Ranger
PDF
Facilitating Internal Physician Contracting Conversations
PPTX
Trends in Hospital-Based Agreements
PDF
Defining, Determining, and Documenting FMV for Medical Directorships
PDF
Addressing Changes in Benchmarks
PPTX
Defining, Determining, and Documenting FMV
PDF
Mitigating Physician Contracting Risk
PPTX
5 Key Tips for Enhancing Physician Relationships
PPTX
Mitigating Stacking Risks
Key Findings from MD Ranger’s 2020 Facility Totals Benchmarks
10th Anniversary Webinar Series: The Definitive Guide to Emergency Call Coverage
Compliance and Legal Risks in Laborist, Surgicalist, and Hospitalist Arrangem...
Audit Physician Contracts the Smart Way
Outside of FMV Range? Now What?
What You Need to Know from HCCA's 2019 Compliance Institute
Perfecting Your Physician Contracting Program
Uncovering Best Practices from Corporate Integrity Agreements
Physician Contracting at Small and Rural Hospitals
Stark Law Basics
What to Do When You're Out of FMV Range
Auditing Physician Contracts with MD Ranger
Facilitating Internal Physician Contracting Conversations
Trends in Hospital-Based Agreements
Defining, Determining, and Documenting FMV for Medical Directorships
Addressing Changes in Benchmarks
Defining, Determining, and Documenting FMV
Mitigating Physician Contracting Risk
5 Key Tips for Enhancing Physician Relationships
Mitigating Stacking Risks

Recently uploaded (20)

PPT
12.Biomechanical Preparation final (2).ppt
PPTX
unit 1 community health nursing , community
PPTX
Abdominal Ultrsound - Session 5 - Dr Vibhu -Ultrasonography of the spleen an...
PPTX
Health and wellness (Chapter 7).pptx for dpt
PPTX
#15 ANS & SNS Anatomy BY DR. SADAKAT.pptx
PPTX
OBSTRUCTIVE SLEEP APNOEA- features and management
PPTX
Common Bacterial infections-converted_64bcdc4f77a3b7b90bdeb611f66c6ddd.pptx
PPTX
BLS – Basic Life Support ppt for nursing
PPTX
Physiological Changes in Pregnancy.pptx..
PDF
Chapter 8. HHS Facility Design and Construction _ HHS.gov.pdf
PDF
4_PHAS 609 Clinical Medicine I Lecture 1.pdf
PPTX
Emotional Well Being & Conflict Resolution_VKV.pptx
PPTX
Seizures in paediatrics as a big cause of morbidity.pptx
PPTX
Symphosium Dr saurab ad Dr. Khushbu.pptx
PDF
18-23_Weeks_Scan ultrsasound scan in medecine.pdf
PPT
53afocus7fluidelectrolytesacid-basebalance-121205082904-phpapp01.ppt
PDF
Terrifying Peripartum Cardiomyopathy - Recent Advances.pdf
PPTX
anatomy and physiology of pharynx ( oro and naso and pharyngeal)
PPTX
Airway Management Emergency department presentation .pptx
PDF
Joint Commission EBPCD24_samplepages.pdf
12.Biomechanical Preparation final (2).ppt
unit 1 community health nursing , community
Abdominal Ultrsound - Session 5 - Dr Vibhu -Ultrasonography of the spleen an...
Health and wellness (Chapter 7).pptx for dpt
#15 ANS & SNS Anatomy BY DR. SADAKAT.pptx
OBSTRUCTIVE SLEEP APNOEA- features and management
Common Bacterial infections-converted_64bcdc4f77a3b7b90bdeb611f66c6ddd.pptx
BLS – Basic Life Support ppt for nursing
Physiological Changes in Pregnancy.pptx..
Chapter 8. HHS Facility Design and Construction _ HHS.gov.pdf
4_PHAS 609 Clinical Medicine I Lecture 1.pdf
Emotional Well Being & Conflict Resolution_VKV.pptx
Seizures in paediatrics as a big cause of morbidity.pptx
Symphosium Dr saurab ad Dr. Khushbu.pptx
18-23_Weeks_Scan ultrsasound scan in medecine.pdf
53afocus7fluidelectrolytesacid-basebalance-121205082904-phpapp01.ppt
Terrifying Peripartum Cardiomyopathy - Recent Advances.pdf
anatomy and physiology of pharynx ( oro and naso and pharyngeal)
Airway Management Emergency department presentation .pptx
Joint Commission EBPCD24_samplepages.pdf

Stop the Financial Bleed: Triaging the Cost of Hospital-Based Physician Services

  • 1. Stop the Financial Bleed: Triaging the Costs of Hospital-Based Physician Services October 2018
  • 2. Agenda § Host introductions § Hospital-based arrangements: § The basics § Payment mechanisms § Key considerations and best practices § Case study 2
  • 3. Your Hosts Luis Argueso § 10+ years of valuation experience with hospital-based service arrangements § Author of numerous articles on fair market value, commercial reasonableness, compensation trends, and telemedicine § Consulting experience with hospitals and provider groups regarding hospital-based service lines Allison Pullins § 6+ years on the leadership team at MD Ranger; 12+ years of industry experience § Helped hundreds of hospitals use market benchmarks and tools to enhance their physician contracting programs § Hosted 55+ webinars on physician services, FMV documentation, compliance best practices, and more 3 Stephanie Tafoya § 2+ years of compensation valuation experience § Prior to working on valuations, 5 years of experience managing physician compensation survey data at MGMA § Author of articles demonstrating proper use of benchmark data
  • 5. Common and Emerging Specialties § Anesthesia § Critical care/Intensivists § Emergency Medicine § Hospitalists § General Hospitalists § OB Hospitalists (aka “Laborists”) § Psychiatric Hospitalists § Pediatric Hospitalists § Orthopedic Hospitalists § Surgical Hospitalists (aka “Surgicalists”) § Neonatology § Pathology § Radiology § Trauma 5
  • 6. Growth Demonstrated in Benchmarks 6 Source: MD Ranger
  • 7. Financial Assistance Needed § Sometimes professional services revenue insufficient § Why? § Payor mix § Coverage requirements § Volume § Specialty § Market factors 7
  • 8. Hospital-Based Arrangements Grow in Scope 8 § MD Ranger tracks hospitals’ spending on physician contracts in aggregate § Over the past three years, we’ve seen growth in hospital spending for these types of services Source: MD Ranger
  • 9. When You’ve Seen One, You’ve Seen Only One § Each hospital arrangement is unique § Benchmarks can be guideposts § Careful analysis needed for all hospital-based arrangements 9
  • 10. Key Trends § Ever-increasing costs due to reduced volumes § Higher demand for services § Continued bifurcation of hospital-based “versus” office-based physicians § Specialty hospitalist services 10
  • 12. Subsidies § Cost of the services exceed the anticipated professional revenue § Provider bills and collects § Flat payment is negotiated § Market benchmarks are available 12 Source: MD Ranger 2018 Reports
  • 13. Collection Guarantees § Cost of the services exceed the anticipated professional revenue § Also known as a “Revenue Guarantee” § Provider bills and collects § Flat payments are occasionally made § Parties meet regularly to reconcile the practice’s revenue against the guarantee amount § Hospital pays for remaining shortfall or practice refunds the excess 13 Cost to Provide Services Payment Professional Collections
  • 14. Payment Mechanisms by Service 14 Source: MD Ranger 2018 Reports
  • 15. Call Coverage Payments on the Rise 15 Source: MD Ranger
  • 17. Staffing § Is proposed staffing level reasonable? § Look at time requirements, production levels § Note: physician-only staffing will likely result in fewer FTE’s but higher costs § Heavy on APPs? Costs could decrease 17
  • 18. Provider Compensation § Primary cost-driver § Keep in mind: § Location § Recruitment challenges? § On-call coverage issues? § Production levels? § Visit www.hcfmv.com for Stephanie’s insights regarding the nuances of compensation benchmarking 18
  • 19. Run to Benchmarks § Market benchmarks are available for total annual payments in hospital based arrangements § Benchmarks are useful to understand where your agreement payment falls relative to other arrangements in the specialty § Use benchmarks with great care 19
  • 20. Operating Expenses § Billing and collecting expenses § Malpractice § Legal, accounting § Taxes § Insurance § Miscellaneous 20
  • 21. Expertise in Marketplace & FMV 21 § Your organization should have access to experts who: § Know and understand hospital-based service arrangements § Understand your organization’s profile (AMC? Critical access?) § Latest trends in hospital-based service lines § FMV and commercial reasonableness § Don’t have such expertise internally? Hire a consultant who can help
  • 22. CASE STUDY: EMERGENCY MEDICINE AT SYCAMORE HOSPITAL* 22 *pseudonym
  • 23. Reimbursement Changes Prompt Renegotiation § Physician group expects reduction in commercial payor revenue § Hospital and physician group need to negotiate new agreement § Hospital embarks on analysis of service line 23
  • 24. Sources of Revenue Analysis § Payor mix comparison § Collections per visit comparison § Collections per wRVU 24 HCUP EM “Poor” Payor %: 45.7% HCUP Benchmark Payor Mix
  • 25. Efficiency Analysis § Throughput comparison § w/RVUs per hour § Measure ED acuity 25
  • 26. Key Take-Aways 26 Review Market Data •MD Ranger •Compensation surveys •Specialty-specific resources Understand Agreement Terms •Service Level •Payment Mechanism Perform Expert Analysis •Staffing •Operating Expenses •Benchmarking
  • 27. Need support? § Contact us with questions § Download resources on www.mdranger.com or www.hcfmv.com § Follow us on social 27