Section Divider: Heading intro here.




Swinging & Flowing: Inclusion
& diaspora
Helen Milner


Chief Executive, Online Centres Foundation
26 April 2012
Note: Some of the pictures have been deleted from
the slide deck originally presented at UC Berkeley on
   26 April 2012. I replaced images with text where
  relevant in order to reduce the size of the file and
 keep the original data so that none of the meaning
                      has been lost
2,271,944,524
Number of internet users in the
   world February 2012
32.7%
That’s 2,271,944,524 as a % of the
         world population
% of each country/continent’s own population who are internet users
Digital Inclusion: US & UK
• Between 2009 and 2011 an additional 2% of
  the US population became internet users
  – USA 76.3% (Nov 2009)
  – USA 78.3% (Dec 2011)
• Between 2009 and 2011 an additional 7.7% of
  the UK population became internet users
  – UK 76.4% (Sept 2009)
  – 84.1% (Dec 2011)
UK online centres: a national organisation
• Government funded organisation leading,
  coordinating and supporting a national network of
  4,300 venues
• Provide:
   – A learning website for people new to the internet
   – National campaigns and support local events
   – Training and grants to train volunteers & centre
     staff
   – Some grants to c. 1000 centres & outreach activity
     p.a.
   – National partnerships
Technology + Community + Scale



        National + Local
Smarter Government
 Announced: December 2009
 Started delivery: April 2010

 £30m for UK online centres over 3
 years to get 1 million more people to
 become internet users (at about $50
 per person)
Why do we need to put public
      services online?
1m online for £30m: How are we* doing?
             * UK online centres




                                   1 April 2010 – 22 April 2012
People
• Need access to good quality, convenient and
  reliable information and services
  – Tax, education, driving, law, benefits, jobs (Gov)
  – Grocery shopping, learning, news, cheap goods
    (Life)
  – Shopping, weather, catch-up TV, hobbies (Leisure)
• Need to communicate with friends and family
• Need to be part of a community
  – Local community: development
  – Collaborating with others beyond local area
LINK http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9_VVZLAsjUw
Why do we care who uses
       internet?
We’re creating a new inequality




               Percentage UK population use of the internet
               Source: ONS 2010
Internet and peoples lives of Internet Users and Non Users
                 Comparison

                                                             More confident
                                         Self Confidence
                                           4.50
          Informed on local affairs                             Overall happiness

                                           4.00                                            Happier
 Connection to family and
                                           3.50                          Quality of life
  friends who aren't local

                                           3.00
                                                                                Better quality of life
  Confidence expressing
                                                                         Ease of organising
       views to key
                                                                          social gatherings
    decision makers


    Confidence talking to different
                                                                Informed on current affairs
     people on different subjects

                                      Skills to get a new job
                                                                          More informed
        Confident of their skills to get a new job


                      Internet user      Internet non-user


                                                           “Does the internet improve lives?”
                                                           Freshminds April, 2009
Comparison online and
         UK before centres users lives – before and after
after using the internet     I do not feel concerned about my levels
                                 of qualifications, training or skills
                                                                                  Feel less concerned
                                                     n=75                         about skills, work
                                             100%
                                                                                  and health
                                              80%


                                              60%                                     I do not feel concerned
  I communicated as much
                                                                                      about my work position
as I would like to with friends
                                                                                                n=51
                                              40%



Communicate                                   20%

more
                                                0%




   I communicated as much                                                             I do not feel concerned about
      as I would have liked                                                                      my health
         with my family                                                                             n=75
                                                                              Feel more connected to
                                                                              local community

                                      I felt part of my local community



                                            "Yes" Before        "Yes" After


                                                             “Does the internet improve lives?”
                                                             Freshminds April, 2009
In the UK
• £276 savings a year by being online for the
  households with the lowest income
• 25% of all new jobs advertised only online
In the US
• 80% of Fortune 500 companies have online
  only job applications
• Students with broadband at home achieve 6 –
  8% higher high school graduation rates
How do UK employers feel about IT
skills?

• 72% of employers wouldn't even interview entry
  level candidates who didn't have basic IT skills




                     ICM/UK online centres survey, February 2012
The internet makes you happier
            than money
• The BCS research found that:
  ‘IT has a direct positive impact on life
  satisfaction, even when controlling for
  income and other factors known to be
  important in determining well-being’
               Source: The Information Dividend: Why IT makes you
               ‘happier’, BCS, The Chartered Institute for IT by
               Trajectory Partnership, September 2010
100m Americans do not have
     home broadband
66m Americans are digitally
       illiterate
Who is offline in the UK?
(has NEVER used the internet – UK population)
Who is offline in the USA?




1 in 5 American adults do not use the internet
                Source: Pew “Digital Differences”, 13 April 2012
Isource: Internet World Stats http://www.internetworldstats.com/unitedstates.htm#MA
Similar stats
• Missippi 59.3% (June 2010), Lithuania 59.5%
  (March 2008)
  – (Gates Foundation invested $15.2m in Oct 2007
    for four years in internet in libraries in Lithuania)
• Alabama 65% (June 2010), Hungary 65.3 (Dec
  2011)
• USA 78.3%, France 77.2 (both Dec 2011)
• UK 84.1%, Norway 97.2%, Australia 90%
• Main reason don’t use the internet is lack of
  interest in both US (31%) and UK (64%)
• In the US internet adoption has leveled off
• In both countries the rate of use by people
  already online is increasing rapidly



     Source of 64%: Ofcom UK Adults’ Media Literacy Report, 2011

     Source of 31%: Pew “Digital Differences”, 13 April 2012
USA, % adults who use the internet, by
           race/ethnicity




             Source: Pew “Digital Differences”, 13 April 2012
USA, % adults who use the internet, by
      annual household income




             Source: Pew “Digital Differences”, 13 April 2012
Why is there such a difference?
• Between 2009 and 2011 an additional 2% of
  the US population became internet users
• Between 2009 and 2011 an additional 7.7% of
  the UK population became internet users
Could the US achieve more?
Are there things to copy from the
           UK model?
There are three main barriers why more people
don’t more go online?




                         Freshminds 2007 and 2009
Pubs

                                               Broadband Minister
                                               opening a centre in a
                                               barn



Community centres and events




         Cafes


  … and churches, libraries, mosques, youth groups, mobile

3,800 Community Partners + 500 Access Points
3800 Community Partners
              + 500 Access Points
• All independent
• Not owned, managed or directly funded by us
• Not a franchise
• Sign up to a minimum offer of free support
  and access for learning and use of the internet
• All reflect the local community they are in
The centres are independent of us, and
  represent the community they are in

                                         Broadband take-up
                                         by area varies
                                         from 50% to 80%




*IMD = Indices of Multiple Deprivation
Example centre websites replaced
        orginal graphics:
• Pakastan Welfare Association
  http://www.pwaslough.org.uk/
• Bangladeshi Islamic Centre: http://bicentre.org.uk/
• Somali Centre of Golden Opportunities
  http://www.somaligolden.org.uk/
• Bangladesh Youth & Cultural Shomiti
  http://www.bycs.org.uk/
• Migrants Resource Centre
  http://www.migrantsresourcecentre.org.uk/
Monthly user survey April 2011 – February 2012

                                                                           Aged 65+
                                     Unemployed % Disabled % BAME %        %

North East                  33,835             48        20            8              18

West Midlands               92,950             40        23           31              19

Yorkshire and the Humber    48,530             32        27           11              26

North West                  76,368             33        29           20              21

East Midlands               25,093             37        26           15              23

South West                  20,918             29        33            5              30

East of England             24,555             27        29           10              29

South East                  38,685             33        31           17              29

London                      99,835             32        13           64              12

England (all learners)     460,768             34        26           23              21
Why would a community
organisation want to be a UK
       online centre?
1. Online learning games and
courses for people who have no
    or little internet skills or
            confidence
Our digital literacy content:
            New improvements

• Will make our learning environment mobile and
  tablet friendly
• XML based course engine allows for quick
  translation & localisation
• Use of HTML5 local storage will enable
  completion of courses when no internet
  connection is present and synchronisation back
  to the server when internet is present
2. Training for staff and
       volunteers
Supporting Volunteers and Digital
                        Champions
      ●
          Supported and trained
          over 3000 volunteers in
          2011/12

      ●
          Online Become a Digital
          Champion course

      ●
          Supporting your
          community to get online
          workshops
We held a Supporting your community workshop at our City Library,
 e had lots of opportunity to network and gain fresh approaches to
 lunteer working – would highly recommend and very much worth
 ganising for our staff and volunteers " Sarah Graham - Project Officer Newcastle Libraries
3. Web and freephone search
          facility
• And the centre search is syndicated as an API
  and a widget to other websites such as BT (a
  national telephone and broadband supplier)
  and Gov.uk the new Government domain
4. Being part of a network –
  marketing events, facebook,
twitter, link to national partners
              & policy
Partnership campaigns & events
For example, Get online week
• Annual event for 5 years (each Autumn)
• 50,000 people got online during Get Online Week
  all together in 2007, 2008, and 2009
• 90,000 people in 2010 during Get Online ‘Month’
• Mass publicity (newspapers, television, radio
  interviews, corp partner links, blogs, social media)
• Mass coordinated marketing packs – locally
  delivered
• Local events – over 1500 events in 2010
Three national marketing campaigns a year,
supported with local marketing packs
• We also have a twitter account
  @ukonlinecentres
• And a YouTube channel
  UKonlinecentresvideos
5. And we give out some grants
Connect 2 Compete: C2C
•   The US solution?
•   $4bn public-private-non profit initiative
•   A national platform for digital opportunity
•   Including low cost broadband and computer,
    and digital literacy content
Or, are smart phones the answer?
% American adults who go online wirelessly with
             laptop or cell phone




              Source: Pew “Digital Differences”, 13 April 2012
Technology changes everything and
        changes nothing
Technology has already revolutionised the
      way most of us live our lives

   The goal is not to get people using technology,
   it’s about the how people use technology to
   have a positive, and transformative, impact on
   their and others’ lives
983,682
Finish the 1m people online and
save the UK Government £127m net
(that’s $205m net)
It’s not about technology, it’s all
about people
Thank You
helen@ukonlinecentres.com
@helenmilner on twitter
www.ukonlinecentres.com
www.go-on.co.uk

Swinging & Flowing: Inclusion & Diaspora

  • 1.
    Section Divider: Headingintro here. Swinging & Flowing: Inclusion & diaspora Helen Milner Chief Executive, Online Centres Foundation 26 April 2012
  • 2.
    Note: Some ofthe pictures have been deleted from the slide deck originally presented at UC Berkeley on 26 April 2012. I replaced images with text where relevant in order to reduce the size of the file and keep the original data so that none of the meaning has been lost
  • 3.
    2,271,944,524 Number of internetusers in the world February 2012
  • 4.
    32.7% That’s 2,271,944,524 asa % of the world population
  • 5.
    % of eachcountry/continent’s own population who are internet users
  • 6.
    Digital Inclusion: US& UK • Between 2009 and 2011 an additional 2% of the US population became internet users – USA 76.3% (Nov 2009) – USA 78.3% (Dec 2011) • Between 2009 and 2011 an additional 7.7% of the UK population became internet users – UK 76.4% (Sept 2009) – 84.1% (Dec 2011)
  • 7.
    UK online centres:a national organisation • Government funded organisation leading, coordinating and supporting a national network of 4,300 venues • Provide: – A learning website for people new to the internet – National campaigns and support local events – Training and grants to train volunteers & centre staff – Some grants to c. 1000 centres & outreach activity p.a. – National partnerships
  • 8.
    Technology + Community+ Scale National + Local
  • 9.
    Smarter Government Announced:December 2009 Started delivery: April 2010 £30m for UK online centres over 3 years to get 1 million more people to become internet users (at about $50 per person)
  • 10.
    Why do weneed to put public services online?
  • 11.
    1m online for£30m: How are we* doing? * UK online centres 1 April 2010 – 22 April 2012
  • 13.
    People • Need accessto good quality, convenient and reliable information and services – Tax, education, driving, law, benefits, jobs (Gov) – Grocery shopping, learning, news, cheap goods (Life) – Shopping, weather, catch-up TV, hobbies (Leisure) • Need to communicate with friends and family • Need to be part of a community – Local community: development – Collaborating with others beyond local area
  • 14.
  • 15.
    Why do wecare who uses internet?
  • 16.
    We’re creating anew inequality Percentage UK population use of the internet Source: ONS 2010
  • 17.
    Internet and peopleslives of Internet Users and Non Users Comparison More confident Self Confidence 4.50 Informed on local affairs Overall happiness 4.00 Happier Connection to family and 3.50 Quality of life friends who aren't local 3.00 Better quality of life Confidence expressing Ease of organising views to key social gatherings decision makers Confidence talking to different Informed on current affairs people on different subjects Skills to get a new job More informed Confident of their skills to get a new job Internet user Internet non-user “Does the internet improve lives?” Freshminds April, 2009
  • 18.
    Comparison online and UK before centres users lives – before and after after using the internet I do not feel concerned about my levels of qualifications, training or skills Feel less concerned n=75 about skills, work 100% and health 80% 60% I do not feel concerned I communicated as much about my work position as I would like to with friends n=51 40% Communicate 20% more 0% I communicated as much I do not feel concerned about as I would have liked my health with my family n=75 Feel more connected to local community I felt part of my local community "Yes" Before "Yes" After “Does the internet improve lives?” Freshminds April, 2009
  • 19.
    In the UK •£276 savings a year by being online for the households with the lowest income • 25% of all new jobs advertised only online
  • 20.
    In the US •80% of Fortune 500 companies have online only job applications • Students with broadband at home achieve 6 – 8% higher high school graduation rates
  • 21.
    How do UKemployers feel about IT skills? • 72% of employers wouldn't even interview entry level candidates who didn't have basic IT skills ICM/UK online centres survey, February 2012
  • 22.
    The internet makesyou happier than money • The BCS research found that: ‘IT has a direct positive impact on life satisfaction, even when controlling for income and other factors known to be important in determining well-being’ Source: The Information Dividend: Why IT makes you ‘happier’, BCS, The Chartered Institute for IT by Trajectory Partnership, September 2010
  • 23.
    100m Americans donot have home broadband
  • 24.
    66m Americans aredigitally illiterate
  • 25.
    Who is offlinein the UK? (has NEVER used the internet – UK population)
  • 26.
    Who is offlinein the USA? 1 in 5 American adults do not use the internet Source: Pew “Digital Differences”, 13 April 2012
  • 27.
    Isource: Internet WorldStats http://www.internetworldstats.com/unitedstates.htm#MA
  • 28.
    Similar stats • Missippi59.3% (June 2010), Lithuania 59.5% (March 2008) – (Gates Foundation invested $15.2m in Oct 2007 for four years in internet in libraries in Lithuania) • Alabama 65% (June 2010), Hungary 65.3 (Dec 2011) • USA 78.3%, France 77.2 (both Dec 2011) • UK 84.1%, Norway 97.2%, Australia 90%
  • 29.
    • Main reasondon’t use the internet is lack of interest in both US (31%) and UK (64%) • In the US internet adoption has leveled off • In both countries the rate of use by people already online is increasing rapidly Source of 64%: Ofcom UK Adults’ Media Literacy Report, 2011 Source of 31%: Pew “Digital Differences”, 13 April 2012
  • 30.
    USA, % adultswho use the internet, by race/ethnicity Source: Pew “Digital Differences”, 13 April 2012
  • 31.
    USA, % adultswho use the internet, by annual household income Source: Pew “Digital Differences”, 13 April 2012
  • 32.
    Why is theresuch a difference? • Between 2009 and 2011 an additional 2% of the US population became internet users • Between 2009 and 2011 an additional 7.7% of the UK population became internet users
  • 33.
    Could the USachieve more? Are there things to copy from the UK model?
  • 34.
    There are threemain barriers why more people don’t more go online? Freshminds 2007 and 2009
  • 36.
    Pubs Broadband Minister opening a centre in a barn Community centres and events Cafes … and churches, libraries, mosques, youth groups, mobile 3,800 Community Partners + 500 Access Points
  • 37.
    3800 Community Partners + 500 Access Points • All independent • Not owned, managed or directly funded by us • Not a franchise • Sign up to a minimum offer of free support and access for learning and use of the internet • All reflect the local community they are in
  • 38.
    The centres areindependent of us, and represent the community they are in Broadband take-up by area varies from 50% to 80% *IMD = Indices of Multiple Deprivation
  • 39.
    Example centre websitesreplaced orginal graphics: • Pakastan Welfare Association http://www.pwaslough.org.uk/ • Bangladeshi Islamic Centre: http://bicentre.org.uk/ • Somali Centre of Golden Opportunities http://www.somaligolden.org.uk/ • Bangladesh Youth & Cultural Shomiti http://www.bycs.org.uk/ • Migrants Resource Centre http://www.migrantsresourcecentre.org.uk/
  • 40.
    Monthly user surveyApril 2011 – February 2012 Aged 65+ Unemployed % Disabled % BAME % % North East 33,835 48 20 8 18 West Midlands 92,950 40 23 31 19 Yorkshire and the Humber 48,530 32 27 11 26 North West 76,368 33 29 20 21 East Midlands 25,093 37 26 15 23 South West 20,918 29 33 5 30 East of England 24,555 27 29 10 29 South East 38,685 33 31 17 29 London 99,835 32 13 64 12 England (all learners) 460,768 34 26 23 21
  • 41.
    Why would acommunity organisation want to be a UK online centre?
  • 42.
    1. Online learninggames and courses for people who have no or little internet skills or confidence
  • 45.
    Our digital literacycontent: New improvements • Will make our learning environment mobile and tablet friendly • XML based course engine allows for quick translation & localisation • Use of HTML5 local storage will enable completion of courses when no internet connection is present and synchronisation back to the server when internet is present
  • 46.
    2. Training forstaff and volunteers
  • 47.
    Supporting Volunteers andDigital Champions ● Supported and trained over 3000 volunteers in 2011/12 ● Online Become a Digital Champion course ● Supporting your community to get online workshops We held a Supporting your community workshop at our City Library, e had lots of opportunity to network and gain fresh approaches to lunteer working – would highly recommend and very much worth ganising for our staff and volunteers " Sarah Graham - Project Officer Newcastle Libraries
  • 48.
    3. Web andfreephone search facility
  • 50.
    • And thecentre search is syndicated as an API and a widget to other websites such as BT (a national telephone and broadband supplier) and Gov.uk the new Government domain
  • 51.
    4. Being partof a network – marketing events, facebook, twitter, link to national partners & policy
  • 52.
  • 53.
    For example, Getonline week • Annual event for 5 years (each Autumn) • 50,000 people got online during Get Online Week all together in 2007, 2008, and 2009 • 90,000 people in 2010 during Get Online ‘Month’ • Mass publicity (newspapers, television, radio interviews, corp partner links, blogs, social media) • Mass coordinated marketing packs – locally delivered • Local events – over 1500 events in 2010
  • 54.
    Three national marketingcampaigns a year, supported with local marketing packs
  • 56.
    • We alsohave a twitter account @ukonlinecentres • And a YouTube channel UKonlinecentresvideos
  • 57.
    5. And wegive out some grants
  • 58.
    Connect 2 Compete:C2C • The US solution? • $4bn public-private-non profit initiative • A national platform for digital opportunity • Including low cost broadband and computer, and digital literacy content
  • 60.
    Or, are smartphones the answer? % American adults who go online wirelessly with laptop or cell phone Source: Pew “Digital Differences”, 13 April 2012
  • 61.
    Technology changes everythingand changes nothing
  • 62.
    Technology has alreadyrevolutionised the way most of us live our lives The goal is not to get people using technology, it’s about the how people use technology to have a positive, and transformative, impact on their and others’ lives
  • 63.
    983,682 Finish the 1mpeople online and save the UK Government £127m net (that’s $205m net)
  • 66.
    It’s not abouttechnology, it’s all about people
  • 67.
    Thank You [email protected] @helenmilner ontwitter www.ukonlinecentres.com www.go-on.co.uk

Editor's Notes

  • #2 I want to give three cheers for international women everywhere – My first woman I want to raise a glass to is Betty ….
  • #10 This argument was then picked up by Gordon Brown and led to UK online centres being awarded £30m to an additional 1m people online between 2010-2013
  • #15 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9_VVZLAsjUw
  • #18 25% more confident that they have the skills to get a new job http://www.ukonlinecentres.com/corporate/content/view/11/112/lang,en/
  • #19 http://www.ukonlinecentres.com/corporate/content/view/11/112/lang,en/
  • #37 Working closely with almost 4000 community partners – in pubs, community centres, cafes, churches, libraries, mosques, buses, etc
  • #39 It’s appropriate for us to now focus on the people who are in most need to get online and get digital skills. The people who are the most excluded are: older people; disable people; and people from the most disadvantaged communities (such as the 10% most disadvantaged measured by the Indices of Multiple Deprivation). So we will develop three specialist networks, one for each of these groups – we will do this so that we can promote these centres in a more targeted way, ensure that we work with the right national and local partners, and we will develop new services so that they can achieve more focusing on talking to learners in these excluded groups so that we can prioritise investment on the services that will have greatest impact.
  • #45 Splash & Grab is an example game we’ve produced
  • #53 We do that in centres and through national partnership campaigns
  • #55 People are supported by digital champions – at home by family, and in centres by thousands of volunteers
  • #63 Benefits vs risks