The digital
conundrum:
digital health
and/or wellbeing
Plymouth College of Art
Debbie Holley, Professor of Learning Innovation
Ben Goldsmith, Learning Technologist
Bournemouth University
Photo by Kent Pilcher on Unsplash
• Quick policy overview to set context
• The student experience
• Activities
• Tech v Human approaches
• Solutions and discussions
#digitalembed
@debbieholley1
https://tinyurl.com/vouqlse
EU Digicomp
Jisc Digital Insights
The UK (JISC) and EU
(DigiComp) frameworks have
both been updated to include
digital wellbeing …
Office for Students: Digital poverty report 2020
52% of students report their
learning impacted by slow or
reliable internet connection
8% severely
71 per cent reported lack of
access to a quiet study
space, with 22 per cent
‘severely’ impacted
56 per cent said they lacked
access to appropriate online
course materials, with 9 per
cent ‘severely’ impacted
18 per cent were impacted
by lack of access to a
computer, laptop or tablet –
4 per cent said they were
‘severely’ impacted.
4% of students do not use
the internet
Student Mental Health:
• Measures must be taken to ensure no student is affected by
digital poverty. At the pre–arrival stage (and prior to the
commencement of each academic year) institutions should
engage students to understand their ability to access
remote learning, and ensure students can access the tools
they need to succeed, taking steps to remove barriers to
access (e.g. affordability). Student minds: Life in
a pandemic (2021)
• “Long lectures (3 hours) make it hard to stay motivated
when staring at a laptop screen and juggling poor Wi–Fi,
lack of privacy and disruptions within the home. These
issues make it difficult to concentrate.” Student quote in
the Student Digital Experience Survey by Jisc, 2021
Photo by Elisa Ventur on Unsplash
Activity 2 • In chat – what ideas do you have to helping our students achieve that
balance....
JISC Digital wellbeing definition:
Impact of technologies and digital
services on students’ and staff’s mental,
physical and emotional health.
The 'tree metaphor' is drawn from one of
their workshops'
New report: (Jisc 2020) Student and staff
wellbeing in Higher Education
Activity 3 Draw a tree with both roots and branches
Technical connectivity versus human connections
Image credit: Anne Quinney free for reuse with credit
Technical
connectivity
versus human
connections
How might we promote wellbeing
through human connections in an online
environment?
Image Credit: University of Arizona Libraries
A more health related one
we use with students
• Activity 4: Using QR
codes for your discipline
https://www.youtube.com
/watch?v=XKbwmTG8chQ
And possibilities of now?
• Martian Attack:
• Our paramedic team ran a simulation in our underground car park last month.
• 3D 360-film clips created from the session captured scenarios, simulations and debrief, and are hosted on Panopto,
and thus accessible by a range of technologies, from google cardboards, to OCULUS Quest
Project lead: Adam Bancroft
https://bournemouth.cloud.panopto.eu/Panopto/Pages/Viewer.aspx?id=
d91e4640-de42-45ee-beae-ad2f00cecebe
https://www.flowerweb.com/en/article/191194/12-most-beautiful-trees-in-the-world
3. When you have finished your tree, please
photograph and post your photograph to our
padlet
https://bu.padlet.org/bgoldsmith4/Plymouth
2. Use the roots of the
tree to illustrate the
positive contributions we
can make in supporting
students’ online learning
and digital wellbeing.
Activity 5
1. Earlier we asked you to photograph
or draw a tree
• On each branch briefly note one of
the challenges our students can
face in becoming confident online
learners and citizens
Gif Lord of the Rings pippin tree moving
https://gph.is/11oMggi
What next? We could co-create a resource for the LearnHigher resource bank! If you are interested
email your tree images to Ben (bgoldsmith@bournemouth.ac.uk) with 'Trees' in the title. The LH
resource bank had over 3 million hits on the site last year!
What next? (optional!)
And try out: relaxation
This is the link:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?
v=7AkbUfZjS5k&t=60s
Final activity! Chill....and
design to include breaks
for your students....
Selected references
• Bleckmann., P Holley, D and Bitzer, E. (2021) Digital balance literacy: a model for supporting wellbeing in the digital era ALT C 2021, 7-9 September (Online)
• https://www.slideshare.net/debbieholley1/digital-balance-literacy-a-model-for-supporting-wellbeing-in-the-digital-era
• Goldsmith et al The best way of promoting Digital wellbeing in HE? https://lmutake5.wordpress.com/2020/09/24/take5-47-the-best-way-of-promoting-digital-
wellbeing-in-he
• Holley, D Jisc: (1.12.2020) Building a better future 'Culture and Resilience' at a time of Covid-19. an ‘In conversation’ piece with Jess Moore, Cameron Mirza
and Dr Sarah Joneshttps://www.jisc.ac.uk/news/building-a-better-future-01-dec-2020
• Pulman AJ, Galvin K, Hutchings M, Todres L, Quinney A, Ellis-Hill C& Atkins P. (2012) Empathy and dignity through technology: using lifeworld-led multimedia
to enhance learning about the head, heart and hand. Electronic Journal of e-Learning 10(3) 320-330

The digital conundrum: digital health and/or wellbeing?

  • 1.
    The digital conundrum: digital health and/orwellbeing Plymouth College of Art Debbie Holley, Professor of Learning Innovation Ben Goldsmith, Learning Technologist Bournemouth University Photo by Kent Pilcher on Unsplash • Quick policy overview to set context • The student experience • Activities • Tech v Human approaches • Solutions and discussions #digitalembed @debbieholley1
  • 4.
    https://tinyurl.com/vouqlse EU Digicomp Jisc DigitalInsights The UK (JISC) and EU (DigiComp) frameworks have both been updated to include digital wellbeing …
  • 5.
    Office for Students:Digital poverty report 2020 52% of students report their learning impacted by slow or reliable internet connection 8% severely 71 per cent reported lack of access to a quiet study space, with 22 per cent ‘severely’ impacted 56 per cent said they lacked access to appropriate online course materials, with 9 per cent ‘severely’ impacted 18 per cent were impacted by lack of access to a computer, laptop or tablet – 4 per cent said they were ‘severely’ impacted. 4% of students do not use the internet
  • 6.
    Student Mental Health: •Measures must be taken to ensure no student is affected by digital poverty. At the pre–arrival stage (and prior to the commencement of each academic year) institutions should engage students to understand their ability to access remote learning, and ensure students can access the tools they need to succeed, taking steps to remove barriers to access (e.g. affordability). Student minds: Life in a pandemic (2021) • “Long lectures (3 hours) make it hard to stay motivated when staring at a laptop screen and juggling poor Wi–Fi, lack of privacy and disruptions within the home. These issues make it difficult to concentrate.” Student quote in the Student Digital Experience Survey by Jisc, 2021 Photo by Elisa Ventur on Unsplash
  • 7.
    Activity 2 •In chat – what ideas do you have to helping our students achieve that balance....
  • 8.
    JISC Digital wellbeingdefinition: Impact of technologies and digital services on students’ and staff’s mental, physical and emotional health. The 'tree metaphor' is drawn from one of their workshops' New report: (Jisc 2020) Student and staff wellbeing in Higher Education
  • 9.
    Activity 3 Drawa tree with both roots and branches
  • 10.
    Technical connectivity versushuman connections Image credit: Anne Quinney free for reuse with credit
  • 11.
    Technical connectivity versus human connections How mightwe promote wellbeing through human connections in an online environment?
  • 12.
    Image Credit: Universityof Arizona Libraries
  • 13.
    A more healthrelated one we use with students • Activity 4: Using QR codes for your discipline https://www.youtube.com /watch?v=XKbwmTG8chQ
  • 14.
    And possibilities ofnow? • Martian Attack: • Our paramedic team ran a simulation in our underground car park last month. • 3D 360-film clips created from the session captured scenarios, simulations and debrief, and are hosted on Panopto, and thus accessible by a range of technologies, from google cardboards, to OCULUS Quest Project lead: Adam Bancroft https://bournemouth.cloud.panopto.eu/Panopto/Pages/Viewer.aspx?id= d91e4640-de42-45ee-beae-ad2f00cecebe
  • 15.
    https://www.flowerweb.com/en/article/191194/12-most-beautiful-trees-in-the-world 3. When youhave finished your tree, please photograph and post your photograph to our padlet https://bu.padlet.org/bgoldsmith4/Plymouth 2. Use the roots of the tree to illustrate the positive contributions we can make in supporting students’ online learning and digital wellbeing. Activity 5 1. Earlier we asked you to photograph or draw a tree • On each branch briefly note one of the challenges our students can face in becoming confident online learners and citizens
  • 16.
    Gif Lord ofthe Rings pippin tree moving https://gph.is/11oMggi What next? We could co-create a resource for the LearnHigher resource bank! If you are interested email your tree images to Ben ([email protected]) with 'Trees' in the title. The LH resource bank had over 3 million hits on the site last year! What next? (optional!)
  • 17.
    And try out:relaxation This is the link: https://www.youtube.com/watch? v=7AkbUfZjS5k&t=60s Final activity! Chill....and design to include breaks for your students....
  • 18.
    Selected references • Bleckmann.,P Holley, D and Bitzer, E. (2021) Digital balance literacy: a model for supporting wellbeing in the digital era ALT C 2021, 7-9 September (Online) • https://www.slideshare.net/debbieholley1/digital-balance-literacy-a-model-for-supporting-wellbeing-in-the-digital-era • Goldsmith et al The best way of promoting Digital wellbeing in HE? https://lmutake5.wordpress.com/2020/09/24/take5-47-the-best-way-of-promoting-digital- wellbeing-in-he • Holley, D Jisc: (1.12.2020) Building a better future 'Culture and Resilience' at a time of Covid-19. an ‘In conversation’ piece with Jess Moore, Cameron Mirza and Dr Sarah Joneshttps://www.jisc.ac.uk/news/building-a-better-future-01-dec-2020 • Pulman AJ, Galvin K, Hutchings M, Todres L, Quinney A, Ellis-Hill C& Atkins P. (2012) Empathy and dignity through technology: using lifeworld-led multimedia to enhance learning about the head, heart and hand. Electronic Journal of e-Learning 10(3) 320-330

Editor's Notes

  • #11   Digital wellbeing is about connectivity and connection. Alongside these new opportunities are challenges and threats These include online-bullying and trolling; highly curated Instagram accounts which increase peer pressure for portraying a ‘perfect’ life  and the concerns this promotes for self-image and body image.  Throughout our teaching & learning endeavors we know about inequalities in access to technology in terms of connectivity, devices, software......families sharing one device; economic impact of lost job opportunities and the health implications that working and studying on line can create – eg poor posture. The impact of social isolation on young people and pressures of home-schooling for mature students.  We know there are increasing numbers of young people experiencing mental health challenges.  Some students have thrived in an online environment – able to join in the discussion boards rather than being reluctant to participate in campus settings, asynchronous materials can be accessed flexibly, avoid a long and expensive commute to campus etc
  • #12 What role might we as educators play in promoting and ensuring digital wellbeing?   We can, for example, focus on relational, life-world led student-centred pedagogies and on developing and promoting social presence (of ourselves and of students) in our teaching & learning activity.  
  • #16 Resources needed: 5 different trees printed on A3 thick card. Post-it notes of leaves. Green oblong post-it notes to go along the roots. Pens or pencils or thin felt tips.