Thoughts on Cybersecurity
- 1. Thoughts on Cybersecurity informed by large international science & the Open Science Grid Frank Würthwein OSG Executive Director UCSD/SDSC
- 2. Let’s reset your perception first
- 3. Jensen Huang keynote @ SC19 3 The Largest Cloud Simulation in History 50k NVIDIA GPUs in the Cloud 350 Petaflops for 2 hours Distributed across US, Europe & Asia Saturday morning before SC19 we bought all GPU capacity that was for sale in Amazon Web Services, Microsoft Azure, and Google Cloud Platform worldwide
- 4. Science with 51,000 GPUs achieved as peak performance 4 Time in Minutes Each color is a different cloud region in US, EU, or Asia. Total of 28 Regions in use. Peaked at 51,500 GPUs ~380 Petaflops of fp32 I can purchase a 300PFLOP32 hour in the cloud for $15k today and nobody asks me any questions about cybersecurity. • Nothing about my nationality or visa or … • Nothing about two-factor authentication or my software • Everything is wide open on the internet
- 5. Should cybersecurity requirements imposed on open academic research executed at on- prem resources be adjusted to the realities of executing the same research on cloud resources ?
- 6. Science is an International Team Sport
- 7. Science is a Team Sport 7
- 8. The ATLAS Collaboration 8 ∼200 institutions across ∼40 countries
- 9. Cybersecurity enabling Science • Humanity has built extraordinary instruments by pooling human and financial resources globally. • To derive science from the data and simulations for those instruments requires globally integrated Cyberinfrastructure. • Cybersecurity is enabling this science. Policy framework Operational security Infrastructure software 9 Disk space use per site by CMS
- 10. XENON Collaboration as a “Midscale” Instrument Example
- 11. XENON1T Storage & Processing Challenge • Experiment in Gran Sasso, Italy • Tape Archive in Sweden • Disk storage in 7 locations across Holland, Italy, Israel, France, USA Petabyte of data divided into 20k datasets • Compute sites on EGI, OSG, and NSF HPC allocation 11 OSG took on the integration challenge via ”embedded” technical support.
- 12. XENON1T Globally Integrated Infrastructure 12 NIKHEF Amsterdam SURFSara Amsterdam Comet XD Allocation IN2P3 Lyon Weizman Tel Aviv OSG integrates HPC allocations, contributions from collaborators, and opportunistic capacity into a single platform to do science on.
- 14. OSG Compute Federation 14 OSG federates ~200 clusters worldwide Owners determine policy of use. Many allow opportunistic use of spare capacity. > 2 Billion CPU core hours per year
- 15. Federation Principle • Any provider can bring their resources to the table. • Truth in advertising: Resource providers accurately specify (some) details about the resource. • Any consumer can decide which of the available resources they are willing to use. 15 OSG matches consumers to providers globally following policies expressed locally.
- 16. “NETFLIX” for Open Science • NETFLIX operates a CDN, providing streaming access to searchable curated data from anywhere at anytime to any subscriber. • For open science, the CDN needs to (in addition) be federated. Anybody can share their data from their locally owned data origin into the CDN. Data Access is mediated via caches in the network and at endpoints to minimize requirements on origins to maximally stimulate sharing. Performance of data access is determined by location and performance of the closest cache rather than the data’s origin. Locally defined and managed groups of users share data securely with each other globally. Data access is global. 16 Locally defined policies are enforced globally by the CDN
- 17. The OSG Data Federation 17 Cur r ent st ashcache infr ast r uct ur e (US) GaTech We operate a production “prototype” of such a CDN
- 18. Two Challenges to think about
- 19. Authz: Person vs Capability • Operations teams are a mix of ”permanent” staff and transients. E.g. CERN pays for ”Operators” funded via ”authorship fees”. • Delegating a person’s identity to a computing activity in order to authenticate the activity at a remote server makes little sense. • Delegating a capability to a computing activity in order to authenticate it at a remote server makes a lot of sense. 19
- 20. Division of Responsibility • To maximize the capacity provided we need to minimize the effort required to provide it. • The services required for the CDN and/or compute federations are specialized and non-trivial. Large learning curve to achieve low cost operations. 20 Service Operations is most (cost) effective when separated from hardware operations
- 21. Network Cache Ops Model • OSG supports the researchers using the Data Federation • OSG deploys & operates the caching middleware. • PRP, TNRP, I2, Regionals, … responsible for network performance. • Hardware owners operate hardware, OS install, and join K8S for container orchestration. 21 Science Applications Data Federation Services Network Performance Hardware & OS A layered approach to distributed DevOps Responsibility
- 22. Cybersecurity Issues (I) • Hardware owners only provide hardware Deploy OS and Kubernetes. • Service Operators (I) A team that operates the K8S cluster. • Service Operators (II) A team that deploys and operates the CDN service as containers inside (and across generally multiple) K8S clusters. • Software Operations A team that provides the container images 22 How do you design a security model that supports this structure?
- 23. Cybersecurity Issues (II) • Container Security Model • Security Model that allows hardware owners to give service responsibility to service operators. Diverse requirements Some institutions will want to operate their own K8S simply because of the level of control that implies. Others won’t because of the level of effort it requires. How do DOE and other National Labs fit into this? How can a service provider in the US operate a service on hardware in EU and Asia? Or vice versa. What about India, Pakistan, China, Iran, … pick your favorite country …. How to deal with institutions that require US Citizenship even for SUDO access? 23 The set of issues and diversity of constraints seems endless And now think back to the beginning: All of this is trivial in the cloud!!!
- 24. Summary & Conclusions 24 • Humanity has built extraordinary instruments by pooling human and financial resources globally. • To derive science from the data and simulations for those instruments requires globally integrated Cyberinfrastructure. • Cybersecurity is enabling this science. Policy framework Operational security Infrastructure software Contact us at: [email protected] Or me personally at: [email protected]
- 25. Acknowledgements • This work was partially supported by the NSF grants OAC-1941481, MPS-1148698, OAC-1841530, OAC-1904444, and OAC- 1826967 25