Week# 6 Tradition vs. 
Science 
By 
M.USAMA MANSOOR
Adopt the Scientific Method 
 Social scientists began to 
 Adopt the scientific method 
 To make sense of the rapid changes 
 Accompanying 
 Modernization and industrialization.
The Development of 
Sociology 
 The development of sociology was 
 Part of a more general trend 
 Toward the development of 
 Discrete scientific disciplines.
Ancient Philosophy 
 In ancient philosophy, 
 there was no difference between 
 the liberal arts of mathematics and 
the study of history, poetry, or politics
Development of Mathematical 
Proofs 
 Only with the development of 
 Mathematical proofs did there 
 Gradually arise a perceived difference 
 Between scientific disciplines and the 
humanities or liberal arts.
Aristotle studied Planetary Motion and 
Poetry 
 Thus, 
 Aristotle studied planetary motion 
 and 
 Poetry with the same methods
Plato Mixed Geometrical 
Proofs 
 And 
 Plato mixed geometrical proofs with 
his 
 Demonstration on the state of intrinsic 
knowledge.
End of 17th Century A New Scientific 
Paradigm 
 However, 
 By the end of the 17th century 
 A new scientific paradigm was 
emerging
Isaac Newton Physics 
 Particularly with the work of Isaac 
Newton in physics. 
 Newton, by revolutionizing what was 
then called natural philosophy, 
 Changed the basic framework by 
which individuals understood what 
was scientific.
Newton Merely Archetype of 
Accelerating Trend 
 While Newton was merely the 
 Archetype of an accelerating trend, 
 His work highlights an important 
distinction.
Mathematical Truth was Objective and 
Absolute 
 For Newton, 
 mathematical truth was objective and 
absolute 
 It flowed from a reality independent of 
the observer 
 and 
 It worked by its own rules.
Other Disciplines Created a 
Pressure 
 In the realm of other disciplines 
 This created a pressure 
 To express ideas in the form of 
mathematical relationships, or laws. 
 Such laws became the model that 
other disciplines would emulate.
Late 19th Century, Mathematical Laws Explain 
Human Behavior 
 In the late 19th century, 
 Scholars increasingly tried to 
 Apply mathematical laws to explain 
human behavior.
Laws of Philology 
 Among the first efforts were the laws 
of philology 
 Which attempted to map the change 
 Over time of sounds in a language
Scientists Sought Mathematical Truth 
Through Logical Proofs 
 At first, 
 Scientists sought mathematical truth 
through 
 Logical proofs.
Early 20th Century Statistics and 
Probability Theory 
 But in the early 20th century 
 Statistics and probability theory 
 Offered a new way to divine 
mathematical laws 
 Underlying all sorts of phenomena.
Statistics and Probability theory 
developed 
 As statistics and probability theory 
developed 
 They were applied to empirical 
 sciences, 
 Such as 
 Biology, and to the social sciences.
Emile Durkheim Explored Human 
Relationships 
 The first thinkers 
 To attempt to combine scientific inquiry 
with 
 The exploration of human relationships 
were Emile Durkheim in France 
 And 
 William James in the United States
Durkheim Sociological Theories and 
Jame’s Work on Experimental 
Psychology 
 Durkheim's sociological theories 
 And 
 James's work on experimental 
psychology had 
 An enormous impact on those who 
followed.

Week# 6 tradition vs. science

  • 1.
    Week# 6 Traditionvs. Science By M.USAMA MANSOOR
  • 2.
    Adopt the ScientificMethod  Social scientists began to  Adopt the scientific method  To make sense of the rapid changes  Accompanying  Modernization and industrialization.
  • 3.
    The Development of Sociology  The development of sociology was  Part of a more general trend  Toward the development of  Discrete scientific disciplines.
  • 4.
    Ancient Philosophy In ancient philosophy,  there was no difference between  the liberal arts of mathematics and the study of history, poetry, or politics
  • 5.
    Development of Mathematical Proofs  Only with the development of  Mathematical proofs did there  Gradually arise a perceived difference  Between scientific disciplines and the humanities or liberal arts.
  • 6.
    Aristotle studied PlanetaryMotion and Poetry  Thus,  Aristotle studied planetary motion  and  Poetry with the same methods
  • 7.
    Plato Mixed Geometrical Proofs  And  Plato mixed geometrical proofs with his  Demonstration on the state of intrinsic knowledge.
  • 8.
    End of 17thCentury A New Scientific Paradigm  However,  By the end of the 17th century  A new scientific paradigm was emerging
  • 9.
    Isaac Newton Physics  Particularly with the work of Isaac Newton in physics.  Newton, by revolutionizing what was then called natural philosophy,  Changed the basic framework by which individuals understood what was scientific.
  • 10.
    Newton Merely Archetypeof Accelerating Trend  While Newton was merely the  Archetype of an accelerating trend,  His work highlights an important distinction.
  • 11.
    Mathematical Truth wasObjective and Absolute  For Newton,  mathematical truth was objective and absolute  It flowed from a reality independent of the observer  and  It worked by its own rules.
  • 12.
    Other Disciplines Createda Pressure  In the realm of other disciplines  This created a pressure  To express ideas in the form of mathematical relationships, or laws.  Such laws became the model that other disciplines would emulate.
  • 13.
    Late 19th Century,Mathematical Laws Explain Human Behavior  In the late 19th century,  Scholars increasingly tried to  Apply mathematical laws to explain human behavior.
  • 14.
    Laws of Philology  Among the first efforts were the laws of philology  Which attempted to map the change  Over time of sounds in a language
  • 15.
    Scientists Sought MathematicalTruth Through Logical Proofs  At first,  Scientists sought mathematical truth through  Logical proofs.
  • 16.
    Early 20th CenturyStatistics and Probability Theory  But in the early 20th century  Statistics and probability theory  Offered a new way to divine mathematical laws  Underlying all sorts of phenomena.
  • 17.
    Statistics and Probabilitytheory developed  As statistics and probability theory developed  They were applied to empirical  sciences,  Such as  Biology, and to the social sciences.
  • 18.
    Emile Durkheim ExploredHuman Relationships  The first thinkers  To attempt to combine scientific inquiry with  The exploration of human relationships were Emile Durkheim in France  And  William James in the United States
  • 19.
    Durkheim Sociological Theoriesand Jame’s Work on Experimental Psychology  Durkheim's sociological theories  And  James's work on experimental psychology had  An enormous impact on those who followed.