Will the real rubric please
         stand up?
          EDEL 335
Will the real rubric please stand up?
Examine the various evaluation tools at
 your table.
What are the strengths and limitations of
 each tool?
Which tool will provide teachers and
 students with the most specific
 information about student learning?
Paragraph ‘Rubric’
 Name                  /1
 Title                 /1
                             • Strengths . . .
 Indent                /1
 Topic Sentence        /2    • Limitations . . .
 Supporting Ideas      /3
 Concluding Sentence   /2
 Handwriting           /2
 Neatness              /2
 Effort                /1
 Total                 /15
Paragraph ‘Rubric’

 Content                 /10
                                • Strengths . . .

 Organization            /10    • Limitations . . .

 Effort                  /5

 Total                   /25


 NOTE: Marks are also awarded
 for neatness and creativity.
Paragraph ‘Rubric’

 Content        4   3   2   1
                                  • Strengths . . .
 Organization   4   3   2   1
                                  • Limitations . . .
 Vocabulary     4   3   2   1

 Sentences      4   3   2   1

 Conventions    4   3   2   1

 Total                      /20
Paragraph ‘Rubric’

  4   •
      •
      •
      •
          (6 bullets)   • Strengths . . .
      •
      •                 • Limitations . . .
  3   •
      •
      •   (5 bullets)
      •
      •
  2   •
      •
      •   (4 bullets)
      •
  1   •
      •
      •   (5 bullets)
      •
      •
Paragraph ‘Rubric’

                            4       3              2             1
  Creates . . .     appealing   purposeful    simplistic    unrelated or
                                                            unfocused


  Organizes   ...   pertinent   relevant      appropriate   unrelated



  Selects . . .     vivid       interesting   routine       basic




                                              • Strengths . . .
                                              • Limitations . . .
Points to Ponder

 What insights did you gain as you
  participated in this activity?
 What questions were generated as
  possible areas for further study?

Will the Real Rubric Please Stand Up

  • 1.
    Will the realrubric please stand up? EDEL 335
  • 2.
    Will the realrubric please stand up? Examine the various evaluation tools at your table. What are the strengths and limitations of each tool? Which tool will provide teachers and students with the most specific information about student learning?
  • 3.
    Paragraph ‘Rubric’ Name /1 Title /1 • Strengths . . . Indent /1 Topic Sentence /2 • Limitations . . . Supporting Ideas /3 Concluding Sentence /2 Handwriting /2 Neatness /2 Effort /1 Total /15
  • 4.
    Paragraph ‘Rubric’ Content /10 • Strengths . . . Organization /10 • Limitations . . . Effort /5 Total /25 NOTE: Marks are also awarded for neatness and creativity.
  • 5.
    Paragraph ‘Rubric’ Content 4 3 2 1 • Strengths . . . Organization 4 3 2 1 • Limitations . . . Vocabulary 4 3 2 1 Sentences 4 3 2 1 Conventions 4 3 2 1 Total /20
  • 6.
    Paragraph ‘Rubric’ 4 • • • • (6 bullets) • Strengths . . . • • • Limitations . . . 3 • • • (5 bullets) • • 2 • • • (4 bullets) • 1 • • • (5 bullets) • •
  • 7.
    Paragraph ‘Rubric’ 4 3 2 1 Creates . . . appealing purposeful simplistic unrelated or unfocused Organizes ... pertinent relevant appropriate unrelated Selects . . . vivid interesting routine basic • Strengths . . . • Limitations . . .
  • 8.
    Points to Ponder What insights did you gain as you participated in this activity?  What questions were generated as possible areas for further study?