Finalists 2013 World Responsible Tourism Awards
Best for Child Protection
and
Best for Responsible Tourism Campaigning
responsible volunteering
SIMPLE priorities
Safety
Informed Consent
Marketing
Purpose
Legacy
Economics
responsible volunteering
“ It’s a time for change –
absolutely it’s a time for change –
we have to start questioning how and what we are
selling as volunteer experiences..........
This is not about selling a beach package –
it creates a shared humanity
or it destroys the more vulnerable.
The understanding of the needs for strong local
partners with good community and ethics is something
that seems to be missed by a lot of the sending
organisations”
Paul Miedema – Calabash Tours, South Africa – speaker at WTM 2012
responsible volunteering

Have we seen
any change
in the last 12 months?
responsible volunteering
Good news
responsible volunteering
Good news
responsible volunteering
Bad news
you can still buy a “deal” for a few hours engaging one to one with children

highlights: “One-on-one reading time with children in the Hope schoolhouse”
responsible volunteering
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=1477
60068756904&set=a.147760065423571.10737418
28.113177318881846&type=1&theater the poster
responsible volunteering
responsible volunteering
Good news
More volunteer organisations with published child protection policies
responsible volunteering
responsible volunteering
Bad news
Do you have child protection policies in place?*
90 volunteer organisations asked
26 responded - 29%
15 declared they have them - 17%
5 make them publicly available or sent proof - 6%
*Question asked of organisations offering opportunities to volunteer in orphanages
and childcare centres on twitter – by @bettrvolunteer
responsible volunteering
Good news
volunteers are starting to report bad experiences
“I went to Uganda. The orphanage where I was volunteering was ultimately closed while I was there.
The shit hit the fan. I was unsafe. The children were unsafe ...
I travelled to Uganda in June and was shocked by our placement.
Not vetted, not legal, corrupt and a pitiful state in which to keep children.” letter to a provider –
if provider doesn't take action it will be made public
“The most vivid memory of my first staff meeting as a volunteer coordinator is the knot in my throat.
The problem being discussed that day was the lack of projects/placements to place everyone
that had been accepted to come. The main office had decided to accept all the requests
and was demanding that we find projects.” a volunteer turned volunteer coordinator –
published on a blog
“Orphanages are not places to visit or volunteer, nor do they help children.
Evidently the message was not clear enough to you when CUCO orphanage in Cambodia was closed
down.
Now, the director of AOEO orphanage, where you also send young volunteers fresh out of high
school, has been charged with the sexual assault of young girls. When will you learn?” on facebook
responsible volunteering
a series of posts on facebook by a volunteer
publicly calling the sending agency to account
responsible volunteering
Bad news
leading organisations are still “getting away with it”
“I had called the office ... while in country to ask for help, regarding the orphanage, and **(local
partner) but was not returned.
I received an e-mail from YY but it did not offer any help and merely pointed me back to **.
Our lives were in danger and this did not matter to the organization.
The greatest complaint I have is with the placement I was given.
It is policy that the organization carefully examines and assesses the project site for a minimum
time frame of six months to one year before volunteers are placed.
This was not the case for us. ** had discovered XXXXX Orphanage the Friday before I arrived ...
and placed us there the following Monday.
The orphanage, located in the slums, was a sham.
We learned that the orphanage was in fact illegal. I have never been so stressed and upset
regarding my time overseas. There is no way I can ever escape the torment of my six weeks
in ?? because I know these innocent children are still at risk.
I know that the man and organization who says they are trying to help them are only furthering
their suffering”

written very recently to a leading organisation that claims to
send “well over 4000 volunteers a year”
responsible volunteering
Good news
young volunteers can find good advice
responsible volunteering
Bad news

young unskilled people are still being led to believe they can change the world

HIGH SCHOOL VOLUNTEER ABROAD
CCS teen summer service trips are for high school
students ages 15-17.
“Join the adventure of a lifetime for
a chance to effect some real social change”
responsible volunteering
Good News
there is lots and lots of advice on what is responsible volunteering

Responsible Volunteering facebook page

Better Volunteering facebook page
responsible volunteering
Bad news
lots of help
to know WHAT to look for

but still little help
on HOW to find it
responsible volunteering
Good news
that’s about to change!

honest and fair information about
responsible and ethical
volunteer travel opportunities
http://bettervolunteering.wordpress.com/
Taking Responsibility

Good News
we can still do this
let’s mend it - not end it!
Thank you

Wtm 2013 responsible volunteering people and places

  • 1.
    Finalists 2013 WorldResponsible Tourism Awards Best for Child Protection and Best for Responsible Tourism Campaigning
  • 2.
    responsible volunteering SIMPLE priorities Safety InformedConsent Marketing Purpose Legacy Economics
  • 3.
    responsible volunteering “ It’sa time for change – absolutely it’s a time for change – we have to start questioning how and what we are selling as volunteer experiences.......... This is not about selling a beach package – it creates a shared humanity or it destroys the more vulnerable. The understanding of the needs for strong local partners with good community and ethics is something that seems to be missed by a lot of the sending organisations” Paul Miedema – Calabash Tours, South Africa – speaker at WTM 2012
  • 4.
    responsible volunteering Have weseen any change in the last 12 months?
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
    responsible volunteering Bad news youcan still buy a “deal” for a few hours engaging one to one with children highlights: “One-on-one reading time with children in the Hope schoolhouse”
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
    responsible volunteering Good news Morevolunteer organisations with published child protection policies
  • 11.
  • 12.
    responsible volunteering Bad news Doyou have child protection policies in place?* 90 volunteer organisations asked 26 responded - 29% 15 declared they have them - 17% 5 make them publicly available or sent proof - 6% *Question asked of organisations offering opportunities to volunteer in orphanages and childcare centres on twitter – by @bettrvolunteer
  • 13.
    responsible volunteering Good news volunteersare starting to report bad experiences “I went to Uganda. The orphanage where I was volunteering was ultimately closed while I was there. The shit hit the fan. I was unsafe. The children were unsafe ... I travelled to Uganda in June and was shocked by our placement. Not vetted, not legal, corrupt and a pitiful state in which to keep children.” letter to a provider – if provider doesn't take action it will be made public “The most vivid memory of my first staff meeting as a volunteer coordinator is the knot in my throat. The problem being discussed that day was the lack of projects/placements to place everyone that had been accepted to come. The main office had decided to accept all the requests and was demanding that we find projects.” a volunteer turned volunteer coordinator – published on a blog “Orphanages are not places to visit or volunteer, nor do they help children. Evidently the message was not clear enough to you when CUCO orphanage in Cambodia was closed down. Now, the director of AOEO orphanage, where you also send young volunteers fresh out of high school, has been charged with the sexual assault of young girls. When will you learn?” on facebook
  • 14.
    responsible volunteering a seriesof posts on facebook by a volunteer publicly calling the sending agency to account
  • 15.
    responsible volunteering Bad news leadingorganisations are still “getting away with it” “I had called the office ... while in country to ask for help, regarding the orphanage, and **(local partner) but was not returned. I received an e-mail from YY but it did not offer any help and merely pointed me back to **. Our lives were in danger and this did not matter to the organization. The greatest complaint I have is with the placement I was given. It is policy that the organization carefully examines and assesses the project site for a minimum time frame of six months to one year before volunteers are placed. This was not the case for us. ** had discovered XXXXX Orphanage the Friday before I arrived ... and placed us there the following Monday. The orphanage, located in the slums, was a sham. We learned that the orphanage was in fact illegal. I have never been so stressed and upset regarding my time overseas. There is no way I can ever escape the torment of my six weeks in ?? because I know these innocent children are still at risk. I know that the man and organization who says they are trying to help them are only furthering their suffering” written very recently to a leading organisation that claims to send “well over 4000 volunteers a year”
  • 16.
    responsible volunteering Good news youngvolunteers can find good advice
  • 17.
    responsible volunteering Bad news youngunskilled people are still being led to believe they can change the world HIGH SCHOOL VOLUNTEER ABROAD CCS teen summer service trips are for high school students ages 15-17. “Join the adventure of a lifetime for a chance to effect some real social change”
  • 18.
    responsible volunteering Good News thereis lots and lots of advice on what is responsible volunteering Responsible Volunteering facebook page Better Volunteering facebook page
  • 19.
    responsible volunteering Bad news lotsof help to know WHAT to look for but still little help on HOW to find it
  • 20.
    responsible volunteering Good news that’sabout to change! honest and fair information about responsible and ethical volunteer travel opportunities http://bettervolunteering.wordpress.com/
  • 21.
    Taking Responsibility Good News wecan still do this let’s mend it - not end it! Thank you