The Ontological Death of Optimization: A Falsification-Based Criterion for Artificial General Intelligence

Abstract

Contemporary approaches to Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) rely predominantly on behavioral benchmarks, optimization performance, and scaling laws. This paper argues that such approaches are ontologically insufficient. Intelligence cannot be verified through behavior or task performance; it can only be falsified through the presence of forbidden ontological structures. We introduce the Ontological Test Suite (OTS), a set of falsification-based criteria designed to identify systems that are ontologically incapable of intelligence, regardless of their performance, creativity, or utility. Grounded in a minimal process ontology (Metamonism CORE v1.3), we formalize intelligence as the continuous impossibility of final stabilization and introduce Unfold as a mandatory, non-representable rupture preventing cognitive selfidentity. OTS does not confirm AGI; it excludes non-AGI. This reframes the AGI problem as one of ontological viability rather than architectural ingenuity.

Author's Profile

Andrii Myshko
Independent Researcher

Analytics

Added to PP
2026-01-29

Downloads
35 (#122,051)

6 months
35 (#119,422)

Historical graph of downloads since first upload
This graph includes both downloads from PhilArchive and clicks on external links on PhilPapers.
How can I increase my downloads?